12 Unique Horror Subscription Boxes to Get Your Spooky On

For horror fans, the days of dread can extend well beyond Halloween. We know that true "horror movie" people live off the thrill and adrenaline of jump scares, plot twists, and psychological mind games.

Fright fanatics can get in a macabre mood every month of the year with monthly horror subscriptions. Whether you're looking for a mildly spooky box club or an out-and-out parcel of terror, the Cratejoy Marketplace is here to deliver. From reading thrilling books and unboxing mysteries to creating a secret society or studying the occult, we've rounded up some of our best horror subscription boxes for you to peruse.

Read on, if you dare…

Top Subscription Boxes for Horror Fans


Skulls Unlimited's BoneBox

From $24.57 per box
Buy Now

What You’ll Get: What's spookier than adding some real skulls to your home decor? Skulls Unlimited's BoneBox is one of the most unique subscription boxes out there, delivering new osteological specimens every month! This creepy crate brings real, professionally cleaned bones, from skulls, teeth, and claws to baculum and other intriguing finds.

Shipping: Ships within the U.S. during the 1st full week of each month


My Thrill Club

From $18.00 per box
Buy Now

What You’ll Get: Thrillers, crime and horror, oh my! If you're a fan of hair-raising, heart-racing genres, My Thrill Club! is the book club for you. Each box brings two hardcover books, plus a bonus e-book, in the creepy category of your choosing. Turn the lights on, lock the doors, and try not to let any chilling screams escape as you read thrillers and mysteries from some of the best horror writers out there.

Shipping: Ships within the U.S. within 2 business days from ordering


Cryptid Crate Monthy Subscription Box - Cratejoy Edition

From $43.00 per box
Buy Now

What You’ll Get: Do you believe in UFOs, aliens, and other paranormal occurrences? Satisfy your penchant for cryptozoology and paranormal-themed items with Cryptid Crate, a monthly subscription box of books, fun wearables, and horror collectibles related to UFOs, ghosts, Bigfoot, and others. These products make great conversation starters for Halloween night, too!

Shipping: Ships worldwide from the U.S. on the 1st weekday of every month


The Resystance

From $31.50 per box
Buy Now

What You’ll Get: Enter a world of days gone by and let the story unfold in front of you as you work your way through the historical mystery you’ll find in Madmen & Heroes' subscription box. Each month brings a new game rooted in history, with plenty of truths to uncover and challenges to work out. If you’re seeking a solution, then a solution you shall find.

Shipping: Ships to the U.S. and Canada during the 2nd and last week of each month


Box of Matter

From $37.46 per box
Buy Now

What You’ll Get: If you love to collect all things interesting, scientific, and maybe even a little bit weird… then have we got a box for you! MATTER is a monthly subscription that specializes in acquiring interesting pieces of, well, matter that are guaranteed to spark your curiosity. Each box comes with a handpicked selection of materials, objects, specimens, or artifacts that will wow anyone who opens it.

Shipping: Ships worldwide from the U.S. on the 4th of every month


This Whodunit is KILLER

From $32.50 per box
Buy Now

What You’ll Get: Just like watching your favorite true crime shows, This Whodunit is KILLER is a monthly murder mystery and investigation game that starts you off at the beginning and takes you all the way through to the end. Horror fans who want in on the action of hunting and convicting the killer can work hard to narrow the suspects down and nail the guilty party.

Shipping: Ships worldwide from the U.S. within 24 hours of ordering, then on the 11th of future months


Paranormal T-Shirt Puzzle Subscription

From $17.00 per box
Buy Now

What You’ll Get: Mystery and suspense are at the heart of all things horrific, so get in the spooky spirit with a T-shirt subscription service that brings a paranormal twist. To start sleuthing, unbox a soft, limited-edition, and intricately designed tee that contains a secret puzzle. Then, find an info card tucked inside, offering clues to uncover a hidden password. Solve it correctly and get a chance to score extra swag!

Shipping: Ships worldwide from the U.S. in the 1st week of every month