Unique Horror Subscription Boxes to Get Your Spooky On

Updated by Timothy Paradis

For horror fans, the days of dread can extend well beyond Halloween. We know that true "horror movie" people live off the thrill and adrenaline of jump scares, plot twists, and psychological mind games. Well, fright fanatics can get in a macabre mood every month of the year with monthly horror subscription boxes.

Whether you’re looking for creepy items or want to know what it’s like to be a detective, you have options - keep reading to learn more: 

Best Horror Subscription Boxes

Whether you're looking for a mildly spooky box club or an out-and-out parcel of terror, the Cratejoy Marketplace is here to deliver. From reading thrilling books and unboxing mysteries to creating a secret society or studying the occult, we've rounded up some of our best horror subscription boxes for you to peruse.

The Cryptid Crate Monthly Subscription Box is a fan-favorite, especially for those interested in aliens, UFOs, and everything paranormal. Each box consists of fun wearables, books, and other unique sci-fi goods.

The Whodunit is KILLER is another monthly box, except this is a monthly murder mystery and investigation game. Now, you don’t have to just watch true crime - you can live it with these interactive games. 

The Skulls Unlimited’s BoneBox is probably one of the most unique horror subscription boxes available. These creepy monthly boxes are filled with some spooky finds, from skulls and claws to teeth. You’ll want to be careful when opening up these boxes. 

With the Sleuth Kings Master Detective: Monsters Madness subscription box, you’ll be transformed into a “Law & Order” episode. Each box comes with a case file filled with puzzles and riddles to help you solve the mystery. If you’ve ever wondered what it’s like to be a detective, this subscription service is for you. 

Spooky season doesn’t have to end in October. If you love anything scary, take a look at these horror subscription boxes:

Skulls Unlimited's BoneBox

Skulls Unlimited's BoneBox

From $24.57 per box
Buy Now

What's spookier than adding some real skulls to your home decor? Skulls Unlimited's BoneBox is one of the most unique subscription boxes out there, delivering new osteological specimens every month! This creepy crate brings real, professionally cleaned bones, from skulls, teeth, and claws to baculum and other intriguing finds.

Shipping: New Subscribers: We ship the 1st full week of the month. Please order by the 30th to get the next month's box. Existing Subscribers: Boxes ship the 1st full week of the month and subscriptions renew on the 15th of every month. *Holidays may cause delays*

"I love this box! All of the bones are high quality, and unique. I love the information about the species with each bone as well. I highly recommend!" - Paige W.

My Thrill Club

My Thrill Club

From $18.00 per box
Buy Now

Thrillers, mysteries, and horror, oh my! For all the fans of hair-raising, palm-sweating genres, the My Thrill Club! serves up everything they need. Every monthly box sends 2 hardcover books, plus a bonus ebook, in the category of their choosing. They'll want to turn the lights on, lock the doors and try not to let the nightmares creep in as they read harrowing stories written by some of the best horror authors.

Shipping: Subsequent boxes will be shipped the first week of each month

"Fun surprise box with books by some favorite authors. Really enjoy these boxes." - Cheryl R.

Sleuth Kings Master Detective: Monster Madness

Sleuth Kings Master Detective: Monster Madness

From $29.95 per box
Buy Now

This birthday, forego the gift cards and opt for a fun monthly subscription that's all about solving a mysterious case. Great for self-proclaimed armchair detectives, Sleuth Kings puts them on the force, giving them a chance to work through a case file alongside the lead detective. They'll dive into the evidence, solve puzzles and ciphers while slowly unraveling what really happened and successfully solving each case.

Shipping: Subscription deadlines are the last day of the month. Case files ship by the 4th of each month! FREE US shipping for Master Detective cases! Subscriptions span 4 cases. Your subscription will automatically end after 4 months. If you subscribe between July 1 - 31, your first case will ship on August 4th.

"My husband and I wanted an activity to do with our fourteen year old son. He loved and we loved it!! It was so much fun figure it out the clues and email the detective. The clues were challenging but not to the point of frustration. It took us two days to solve and we are excitedly waiting for our next case!" - Kim W.

Cryptid Crate Monthy Subscription Box - Cratejoy Edition

Cryptid Crate Monthy Subscription Box - Cratejoy Edition

From $43.00 per box
Buy Now

Happy subscribers attest that the team at Cryptid Crate goes above and beyond, curating delightful collections of all things cryptozoological. A great gift idea for any teen who's into the not-yet-substantiated species of the world, each monthly box delivers 4 to 7 handpicked curiosities, including graphic T-shirts, offbeat decor items, intriguing accessories, and books and films from some of the best independent producers and artisans in the game.

Shipping: - Cryptid Crate ships on the first weekday of every month (will ship a day or two earlier or later if first weekday is a holiday) - Every box will ordered within a calendar month will be included in the shipment that goes out on the 1st.

“Amazing! I was so excited to get this box and it did not disappoint! LOVE the t-shirt and one of my new favorite stickers came in this box. Can't wait for next month!!!” – Megan S.

The Resystance

The Resystance

From $31.50 per box
Buy Now

History buffs know that the world is riddled with unsolved mysteries and strange occurrences. Why not let them take a stab at solving one through ciphers, puzzles, and more either by themselves or with a group? The mystery gets deeper every month.

Shipping: Resystance boxes ship the last week of the month and the cut off for the month for new orders is the 22nd of the month. If you order after that but want the current month's box, just let us know!

“Very interesting story to follow. Loved all the puzzles and cyphers! Definitely a great box if you’re looking for something a little challenging but still fun.” - Sarah G.

Box of Matter

Box of Matter

From $37.46 per box
Buy Now

Described as part museum and part lab project, each month brings objects of intrigue such as rare crystals, ancient fossils, wartime artifacts, natural specimens, and items with scientific significance, like authentic NASA computer chips.

Shipping: Your first box will ship ASAP. The following boxes are shipped monthly. Free US Shipping & reduced international rates. If you have any questions, click the "Contact Seller" button below.

“Probably one of my favorite subscription boxes EVER! If you have kids and they love knowledge and seek out information constantly, this box is an education easter egg that initiates the start of great conversation and exciting exploration into learning. My daughter loved it and my husband and I were kind of jealous, but in a good way.” – Krista T.

This Whodunit is KILLER

This Whodunit is KILLER

From $32.50 per box
Buy Now

A Killing Affair goes digital with the immersive murder mystery in a box and the online components. It's like watching your favorite TV show; subscribers start with the first episode and each season has five episodes. This mystery experience knocks storytelling out of the park.

Shipping: We are committed to getting your first episode to you before Christmas. USPS is currently stating a 4-5 days turnaround. Orders received by noon ship the same day and afternoon are shipped the next day. If you place the order and are worried it will not make it in time we are happy to email a printable certificate for under the tree!

“I recently finished the first season and had to order more. This is just so well done! You get a file folder with witness statements, a case report, and autopsy results for each victim, and there are little evidence bags. Over 5 boxes, the story develops, and you clear some suspects with each box. So much thought went into all of the details! I highly recommend this subscription.” - Stacy B.

Paranormal T-Shirt Puzzle Subscription

Paranormal T-Shirt Puzzle Subscription

From $17.00 per box
Buy Now

Shipping: If your order is received during the first week of the month, it will ship with the current batch. If it is received after that shipment has gone out, your subscription will start the following month.