First I will say this is my first box since signing up. I was hoping for a holiday book themed box, but this is cute. I never watched Gilmore Girls, so I had to look up some of the references.
The phone case: It seems to be well made. It seems to be all leather, with firm stitching, no fraying edges, and a well clasping magnet, that takes a little effort to open, so it won't open on it's own in my purse. The phone sits tight in the holder. I have no fears it's going to fall out.
Coffee sleeve: I don't drink coffee, so I won't use this, but it appears to be sewn together nicely, and seems like it would serve its purpose of not letting your fingers get burned while keeping your coffee warm.
Card: Blank inside card could be cute to send to someone who knows about the show. I don't know anyone who watched the show so the card is irrelevant for me.
Canvas tote bag: Cute bag to carry light items. I will use mine to carry beach shoes and sunscreen. Appears to be well made with a sturdy handle and no fraying edges.
In all for my first box I give it a 5 star. (It's not the company fault I didn't watch the show.) Everything appears well made and full of fun items. Definitely would recommend...