Overall I felt like this was a good gift for bakers who love cookies. I bought it for a friend who loves to bake. I was disappointed that oftentimes the box called for additional items that you needed in order to make the cookies that were not included in the box. I get that fresh ingredients can be shipped but it defeats the purpose of buying an all-in-one box as a gift when they have to buy more stuff to really use it. The add-ons are cute but a little kitsch. I was really hoping to extend this gift for my friend but feel it's not really a complete gift.