I really didn't know what to expect from this box, and had no idea if it would be supermarket wine or something more along the lines of a wine club.
I was extremely pleasantly surprised with the wines I received! I received three wines, two reds and one white, and none of they were supermarket wines, all vintages at least a few years old. The only one I tried was a 2011 Pinot Noir, and it was amazing! I didn't let it sit or use a decanter, and I was surprised to see that it definitely could've used it (because it was a bit tight when I drank it, but still very good).
If there was any feedback I would give it would be to make sure to include a Rosé in my box, as we drink that like water, whereas the others are more for pairings with dinners or special occasions. In my questionaire I filled out that we drink a lot of Rosé, so would just expect to have at least one a month.
All-in-all it was well worth the money and while I haven't priced out the wines yet, I would assume the two reds are at least $25-$30 each, and have high marks, so I'm super happy with this box.
The Red Velvet NYC box was was excellent for this non-baker. I can honestly say the cupcakes were simple to make, beautiful to look at and delicious to eat!!!