Of the 10 subscription boxes I've tried, this is the only one I've continued. (House of Rituals from the same company is also nice but too similar to keep both.)
Items are relevant to my interests, high quality, and enough content to justify the price.
I made the falafel from my box (the only vegetarian option included) but was pretty disappointed with it. Flavor was okay, texture was dry/chewy.
I ordered the Initiate box (June/July 18), and received melty tea-lights, a bar of soap, incense, and a rock on a key chain. I was a bit under-whelmed for the price.