Paper Kitty has a cute collection of items in a nice arrangement. The box was neatly packed, and very thoughtfully put together. Most of my items were post cards or similar things, but I also did receive some washi tape, a pen, a pencil case, and a highlighter as well as some binder clips. I'm more a pen person than anything, so I would have liked to have another pen and maybe a few less postcards. I also wish I had been sent an email with my package info (it appeared on the site under my profile instead).
All in all, this is a very cute box that will fit you perfectly if you're looking for a few sweet items for your desk space.
Saturated in Ink has great customer service and is very professional. I'd never tried a subscription box before, and they answered all my questions promptly and were very friendly. Once I signed up, I was sent an email with more information about them and their website, and when my box was shipped I was sent an email with the tracking number, etc, which I really appreciated.
I am disappointed, though. While the box was packaged nicely, and the items were nice as well, I was really looking forward to a fountain pen, something difficult to find where I am at. I do a lot of writing, and it's far easer to use than a ballpoint. However, when I opened the box there were two calligraphy dip pens, ink, a pen holder, and a notebook (2/3 of which the ink probably won't show up on, as the paper is dark). Calligraphy pens aren't hard to find (or that expensive), and I was really looking forward to my fountain pen. It's not that the set isn't nice, but...when they said "sometimes we include other pens", I thought they meant with the fountain pen, not in place of it. I feel like I didn't exactly get what I paid for, and certainly not what I was really looking forward to.
I'm sure this isn't the norm, but I'll say I was disappointed in the items, purely for the fact that they weren't what I felt I was buying. The service is friendly and...