I have gotten two classic and 1 YA box so far and all of them were filled to the brim with goodies! The items went well with the stories and were mainly made by other small businesses. All boxes shipped fast and in one case when the main book was running late, rather than make everyone wait they put a bonus book into the box and shipped the main one separately when it arrived. I had one issue with an item missing and customer service was fantastic. They put the item in the mail that same day. This is definitely one of the best boxes I have come across and I have been trying them all!