I have been getting Lip Monthly since October and have been mostly very happy with the box. For the price, you always get 4-5 quality products. Obviously, you are never going to like everything that is sent but some of my favorite lipsticks came to me from this subscription. My only complaint is that they used to include a card with descriptions of every product and their retail price, but lately they have stopped sending those- I am sure I could find that info elsewhere though. Would recommend for those willing to try new colors!