My dog was immediately interested in the box when I opened it in front of her. The treats were high quality and have been a big hit, and the toys have been fantastic as well. There was a minor administrative issue but the customer service was efficient and effective in sorting it out. My dog is quite 'snobby' when it comes to toys and snacks and she has gobbled every treat and is still playing with the toys from the first box. 10/10
Two non-peer reviewed (possibly self-published?) "books", six very inexpensive coloured markers and two snack bars that you could buy in the bulk section at any grocery. Very disappointing. One of the books is a 'goal setting book' with a format that school children could download off the internet for free. A significant waste of time and money.