I don't think I'll renew after the 3 boxes that I already paid for. The first one was an awful sparkly plastic thing with 4 separate sharp, stabby edges. Plus the shipping amount for a single bookmark is outrageous. Sad. i loved the idea of this and the photos were all of beaded/metal bookmarks. I am trying to reduce the amount of plastic in my life. if I had known it was going to be plastic, and very low quality, I wouldn't have subscribed.