I paid for a three-month subscription, and received my first shipment a few days ago. The packaging was cute; they stuck with the "tenderloin" theme by wrapping my underwear in a foam tray with plastic, much like a cut of meat would be packaged.
The panties themselves were fine, and they seem to be true to size. I honestly haven't tried them yet, due to inconvenient timing from Mother Nature, but I don't see any problems with the products, and I'm excited to wear them.
My primary motivation in purchasing this box was my desire for some upgrades to my underwear, and no shopping options where I live. Plus, I don't have a ton of experience in the lingerie department, and it's easier to just have someone send some items that I know will be nice. It's a bit more expensive than my typical underwear purchases ($60 for six pairs), but I'm definitely paying for the curated aspect as well as the panties themselves, and I'm happy with my experience thus far. Furthermore, this was my first time utilizing CrateJoy for a subscription service, and I'm pleased it's worked out so well.