The only reason anything lost a star is that I did not want to be misleading. The records, every one I've gotten, have been flawless. The sleeves on the other hand aren't always perfect. I don't think that's a huge deal personally. I've loved what I've received and had a lot of fun with the comedy albums because I've known who half the comedians/acts were but the ones I didn't have been just as entertaining. And a note on shipping- the mailers they're shipped in keep the records very secure and intact I was very very happy with that.
Every box has been unique and interesting. Not "oh... Neat" interesting but legitimately well thought out and fun. The box that came with the little tree was especially impressive. It was so unexpected but perfectly fit with everything else that month. And you really do get a lot for your money with this box.