I love the box and the books I have received. Usually I am very pick about the kind of book I read but I was please with every single book I got. The only downside I would say was the lack of things for my dog. While I got 5 things he only got 2. He doesn't mind of course, he loved the treat and hesitant about the squeaker. I would have loved to see more treats or collars and bandanas and such.