Maybe a step above Whitmans. Very simple, often cheaper fillings. For example, at least 3 or 4 of my last box had marshmallow filling. They were certainly edible and the last box was probably the nicest looking with 2 raspberry filled pieces. However, the auto-renewal is very tricky. On Jackie's site it said they dont do this. But on CrateJoy site it says they do. What's the sense of buying a 3 month subscription if it auto renews. Anyone who wanted continuous would buy a cheaper plan. No easier way to lose a customer than that type of trickery.