I have been a member of this subscription for about two years. About half of the earrings I have received I have loved and consistently wear. The other half are just not my style. Those I keep in their original packaging, then put them out at work as freebies. Only one time have I received a pair of earrings that were broken or of low quality. I sent pictures of the broken earring and quickly received a replacement pair. Overall, this subscription is a good value.