I just started my Cloth and Paper subscription November 2020 after seeing the sneak peak for the spiral planner! Was still planner hunting and once I saw the sneaks I knew it would be my planner for 2021. All the other extras that came in the box were so chic!! I loved the anesthetic of it all! I thought I would only do one box but ended up doing December as well, again due to the amazing sneaks for the vinyl planner! Again the extra stuff in there was so anesthetically pleasing and paired well together. I APPRECIATE that they sneak stuff in advance, so you'll know whether that month's box will be for you or not. I will continue to keep my eye out for the sneaks and get the sub boxes that will work for me. There paper (such as their New Executive Notes included in the Dec sub box) is nice, thick, with some grit to it- perfect for my heavy hand and gel pens. Definitely a Cloth & Paper fan from here on out!!