I subscribed to the Pusheen box for about 18 months, I want to say I received 6 boxes. All of the items were well packed, and never arrived broken. I haven't had any quality issues. Although each item WAS adorable, I had to discontinue because I realized that I wasn't actually using 75% of the items I received.
Overall, if you REALLY like Pusheen, it's a great box. Good variety of items, and the actual shipping boxes were super cute as well.