We got off to a rocky start. My books had been packed incorrectly and were stacked on top of each other long ways in the box with a LOT of room to move around during shipping, which resulted in damage. BUT, Bookcase Club redeemed themselves and sent me a replacement box. I've since reactivated my subscription and will give them another chance. I will say that in both boxes I received, there are no new releases (1x 2014, 2x 2015, 1x 2012) which is a bummer because I'd already read Girl on the Train. I think changing that would make this box a MUCH bigger contender.
I've loved the first book in my first Bookcase Club Box and the second looks just as great! I love that I can change genres each month if I want and that it's a surprise which books will be delivered! So far, very happy I subscribed!