Q: How long will my cookies last? Asked by Nancy M., May 2020
Your Color My Cookie will include a "Best By" sticker on the box. It will be fine at room temperature in its original packaging for at least 6 weeks after it arrives. Please do not refrigerate Color My Cookie.
I don't know. I don't wait to find out. But they're always fresh on arrival.
Q: Are the cookies always holiday themed or can you choose more generic? Asked by Laura K., December 2020
Hi! Our boxes are a mix of holiday and more generic, or "Novelty" themes. Each calendar year, subscriptions include 3 Holiday-themed kits (Valentine's Day, St. Patrick's Day, Halloween); 3 Seasonal kits (Spring, Fall, Winter); and 6 Novelty kits (e.g., Dinosaurs, Outer Space). Please let us know if you have any other questions!
Q: Can I preorder a Christmas box? Are the December cookies Christmas themed?Asked by Sarah S., October 2020
Hi Sarah! I'm so sorry it looks like we missed your question! Yes, you can order a Christmas box individually. We have two Christmas boxes, a Winter box, and a Hanukkah box. All are listed here on Cratejoy for individual purchase. The December box for subscribers is the Winter Box (Let it Snow). Again, we are sorry we didn't see your question when you posted! xx
Q: Can you pick the flavors for the cookies like chocolate chip or oatmeal?Asked by Brandilyn K., August 2020
Hi, Brandilyn!
Color My Cookie is an iced shortbread cookie. It is similar to a sugar cookie, decorated with white and black royal icing, and ready for you to paint at home. Thanks for asking!
Wow, this is a great box! The cookies were not only adorable but tasted great too. My kids had a blast decorating them and they turned out great. Super fun.
I ordered this as a gift for a friend [to cheer her up amidst the pandemic]. Nancy was SO wonderful in helping me through the whole process! Every question promptly and kindly answered and even when there was a confusion [totally my bad], she was very kind to clear it up and went above and beyond.
Love the box AND the bakery!
My boys loved coloring their cookies so much that we had to send these to friends. The cookies are adorable and delicious!
I love the creativity these cookies bring out in the kids. They love "making their own" and then having a yummy treat!!
What a unique, fun cool idea. I ordered these boxes for my grandkids during the quarantine. I have three sets of grandkids living in different states and cities. They range from ages 2-14. It’s not easy to find something that engages all these ages equally. And for some blissful time, they enjoyed one another’s company while they explored their inner artists. My daughter has three boys and three girls, so I ordered what I considered a boy box and a girl box. It was kinda interesting when I saw the videos of the girls busily painting superheroes and the boys painting roller skates and flowers. Just goes to show how versatile these designs are. Oh and I can’t forget, these cookies were devoured. It was also an avenue of being able to be a virtual grandma, when I couldn’t hold and hug them. Thank you Color my Cookie.
An artsy, easy, fun and delicious family activity. The cookies are gorgeous and super high quality, and the paint palettes are ingenious. My kids had a blast painting their cookies. My husband is a connoisseur of shortbread/sugar cookies, and he LOVED them. Highly recommended!
So yummy! Was a fun project for the kids and then they got to eat their work of art!
I’ve really enjoyed sending Color my Cookie kits to friends with grandchildren. I’ve heard back from everyone that their ‘big’ kids had a great time with their little kids decorating, making their cookies into paintings, and eating their masterpieces! I’ve also heard back about Tart Bakery’s delicious high quality sugar cookie. Chef Sam does a great job of taking his listener through the process. Truly a winner cookie kit. 🙂
Color My Cookie makes the perfect gift! We’ve been sending them to friends and family during quarantine to help cheer them up and keep them busy. Everyone has raves about how much fun they are to paint. And even better, they’re so delicious!
January 2022
November 2021
Editor's Pick
Editor's Pick
Editor's Pick
Editor's Pick
Editor's Pick
Editor's Pick
Last Minute Gift? No worries.
Download and print this note to let them know their gift is on the way.