Fresh Baked Cookie Crate

Unbox fun surprises and bake your own gourmet cookies with pre-measured ingredients each month!

Join our cookielicious family! Use code COOKIEFAM19 at checkout to get a special discount!
Plans as low as $20.00 / month
Subscribe Now
Give as a Gift
Product Overview
  • Orders open on the 1st of each month and close on the last day of each month. We ship out the delicious cookie crates on the 1st business day of the month.
  • Only ships within United States
  • Subscriptions automatically renew. Cancel anytime

Unbox fun surprises and bake your own gourmet cookies with pre-measured ingredients each month!

Choose a subscription
The Ultimate Gourmet Cookie Baking Box
The ultimate subscription box for bakers and cookie lovers! Each month, you'll receive pre-measured, vacuum-sealed gourmet, handcrafted ingredients to bake your own cookie. Fool-proof instructions make baking mess-free, and perfect for any level of baker. You'll also receive over $50 worth of fun, cookielicious of surprises and gifts to unbox! 🍪
  • Delicious new cookie every month, never any repeats
  • Gourmet and handcrafted ingredients
  • Pre-measured, mess-free, fool-proof
  • Awesome cookie-themed gifts and surprises
  • Organic, all-natural, vacuum sealed ingredients

Questions

1

Q: In addition to the cookie packs, does the kit include a recipe to be able to make the cookies at a later date?Asked by Heidi I., December 2019

Fresh Baked Cookie Crate answered...December 2019

Hi Heidi!

The cookie crates do not come with the actual recipe. The reasoning
behind this is due to the way we source our ingredients. Many of the
ingredients that we use are gourmet ingredients for businesses or
artisanal handcrafted ingredients. The recipes would not have the
awesome tastes we've curated if translated into easily sourced products.
We will stock past cookie mixes by itself in the cookie shop usually a
month or so after the crate ships. We are also thinking about recreating
the recipes to work for a home baker. We'll post up more info on our
social media sites once we figure out a plan. Please let us know if you
have any more questions that we could help with. Have a great...

Seller

1

Q: How many cookies does each box make?Asked by Donna S., November 2019

Fresh Baked Cookie Crate answered...November 2019

The 2 dozen box makes 24 two inch cookies. The 4 dozen makes 48 two inch
cookies (there are 2 packs of the 2 dozen so you don't have to make them
all at once). Sometimes we make the batch into bite size cookies for the
office and end up with about double the amount. Please let us know if
you have any other questions!

Seller

Fresh Baked Cookie Crate reviewsReviews

Write a Review
10 reviews

Worth the money!

Feb 16, 2020
Elizabeth B.
4 Reviews
Subscribed for 2 months
Overall
Shipping
Quality
Curation

Very cute. Everything is written out clearly and the surprises are super cute

Verified Purchase

First box

Feb 18, 2020
Tara B.
4 Reviews
Subscribed for 20 days
Overall
Shipping
Quality
Curation

Everything is wonderful but its only one dozen cookies. I did not have any batter left after filling in the circles on the provided baking mat

Verified Purchase
Fresh Baked Cookie Crate said...Feb 19, 2020

Hi Tara! We are super sorry for the confusion. The circles are there as a guide to where to place the cookies to keep them from touching each other, for cookies that don't spread (like macarons), and as a general idea on how big they would be after baking. The circles on the baking mat are 2 inches in size. Since batter spreads and rises as they bake, a 1" to 1.5" ball (depending on the recipe) will spread to fill out those circles.

Seller

So cute!!

Dec 11, 2019
Tina P.
1 Review
Subscribed for 25 days
Overall
Shipping
Quality
Curation

Bought this for my daughter. Such a cute box! First box included cookie socks, a candle, silicone baking mat and more!!

Verified Purchase

First box

Dec 10, 2019
Connie H.
1 Review
Subscribed for 25 days
Overall
Shipping
Quality
Curation

This was my first box and I was very pleasantly surprised! I enjoyed the theme and the cookies are great! My only complaint is that my cookies, while edible, are not photogenic. But live and learn!

Verified Purchase

Superb box, even for a guy!

Dec 07, 2019
Michele D.
15 Reviews
5 Pictures
18 Helpful Votes
Subscribed for 23 days
Overall
Shipping
Quality
Curation

OH MY GOSH... what a fantastic box. We got this for our son's 20th birthday and they worked with me to get it here earlier than their normal shipping schedule to allow us to give it to him on time. They even included a gift note AND our birthday note to him beautifully written and decorated :-)

This box is packed full of fun/themed items on top of the tasty recipe and all the dry ingredients needed to make it. They even sent the wearable appropriately sized for a guy, which was AMAZING! I am so glad I chose this bakery box!!! And, most importantly, our son LOVED it. Thank you so much for this awesome box, Fresh Baked Cookie Company <3

Verified Purchase

Delicious, but I must alter a bit

Dec 14, 2019
Donna S.
6 Reviews
4 Pictures
11 Helpful Votes
Subscribed for 15 days
Overall
Shipping
Quality
Curation

I ordered the 4 dozen box and was pleasantly surprised with the quality of the ingredients. Everything was vacuum sealed individually to ensure freshness. The candle smells incredible and the other little surprises were very nice. I baked up one batch to test and glad I did. The cookies, although yummy, were completely flat and thin. Since we live in a high altitude area, I will need to make some adjustments to the recipe besides lowering the temperature to 325°. For the next 2 dozen, I plan on adding a bit more flour and some baking powder. Also, the marshmallows stuck to the sheet making them near impossible to remove. I will correct this by adding them to last minute of baking time. Otherwise, they are tasty and super easy to make.

Verified Purchase
Fresh Baked Cookie Crate said...Dec 14, 2019

Thank you so much for your review Donna! We're so happy that you loved the surprises this month. Unfortunately science gets a little bit in the way with making it totally fool-proof. We did send out an email FAQ with the altitude adjustments as well as many other tips and tricks. If you didn't get it, please add our email address to the approved list as some email clients have been sending our emails to the spam box. :( We did mention the marshmallows needed to be away from the edge on the instruction sheet, but we promise to try and explain it clearer next time to avoid the stickiness. We love feedback like this so we can make things perfect for y'all!

Seller

December Box

Dec 14, 2019
Shelly B.
1 Review
Subscribed for 1 month
Overall
Shipping
Quality
Curation

I absolutely loved the flavor of this cookie!! Unfortunately, I proceeded with recipe I received before I found the email explaining the corrected amount of butter used. This resulted in one large sheet of thin cookies. Still tasted awesome, but difficult to remove and cool.

Verified Purchase
Fresh Baked Cookie Crate said...Dec 14, 2019

Hi Shelly! We are totally sorry you didn't get the message in time! For the troubles, we applied a coupon that will automatically activate on your next renewal. Hope you have a warm and cozy weekend!

Seller

Dec recipe was mailed out incorrectly

Dec 14, 2019
Katie L.
1 Review
Subscribed for 14 days
Overall
Shipping
Quality
Curation

Disappointed. This was my first box. While I was making it, the batter never looked quite right. Too runny. Cookies ended up spreading out in oven and making a cookie pancake. Looked nothing like pic. Turns out, recipe was incorrect. The company sent a letter in mail alerting customers on 12/7, but I didn’t get it in mailbox until a week later. So it was way too late. I feel like the company should send us a complimentary box since we couldn’t even make the correct recipe.

Verified Purchase
Fresh Baked Cookie Crate said...Dec 14, 2019

HI Katie. Due to the error by our printing company, we sent out the incorrect recipe. We tried our best to fix the situation by immediately emailing our customers, twice. We also posted on all of three our social media accounts, our website, as well as sent out the mailed letter that you received. In all those letters we apologized for the error. We also included our email address and asked you to contact us so we can rectify the problem. We have not received an email or message from you and are saddened that you would give us a 2 star rating before giving us a chance to fix things. We will always fix any errors if given the chance. For your inconvenience, we...

Seller

Easy and Tasty!

Jan 14, 2020
Connie H.
1 Review
Overall
Shipping
Quality
Curation

The snickerdoodles are terrific! I was a little intimidated by the burnt butter but I watched the video and it was very easy. I followed the directions, including the suggestion to bake a trial cookie first to test the oven temperature, etc. The cookies turned out great. I used the Silpat mat from the December box on one of the cookie sheets and parchment paper lining on the second. It was amazing how much better the cookies on Silpat looked and tasted.

Better value than other boxes

Dec 07, 2019
Jacqueline F.
4 Reviews
Overall