I got the Three Bottles (ExtraHot) box, and it was exactly what I wanted. Three bottles, all great, plus five small sample packets.
It wasn't just "this one's spicy...yup, this one too." Each bottle was fairly distinct. One very vinegary, another smoky and tangy. The selection was very thoughtful and well done. The sample packets were also good. (I've only tried one packet so far, but two of five are actually from my city, so I'm familiar with them. They're top notch.)
All of them were the spice level I want from an "ExtraHot" box. Ghost pepper and Carolina Reaper? This was done right.
I'm very happy with the quantity and selection, and am eagerly waiting my next box.
Love this! The sauces are FANTASTIC! The variety has been excellent. It is the perfect gift, my fiancé and I look forward to these packages SO much.
Having spent the weekend in the bucolic upper Hudson Valley, I arrived home around 10:30pm on Sunday. Starving after the long drive, I grabbed a bag of pretzels and some hummus. As a Hot Sauce of the Month Club subscriber, I have a wide array of spicy options to add to the hummus. I chose Thor's Hammer, which is a borderline painful sauce, but quite delicious. I headed into the bedroom to unpack my bag, enjoy my snack, and watch Black Widow.
This was unfortunately one too many tasks for me.
I swiped my pretzel through the dip while keeping my eyes on the screen. I felt the hummus container slip out of my hands, and with my cat-like reflexes leaned down to try and catch it before it hit the floor. This did not happen - but it did put my face directly over the hummus-hot sauce mushroom cloud that was about to erupt from my bedroom floor.
As you may have guessed at the point, a substantial glob of scalding hot sauce was shot directly into the center of my right eye - causing me to start screaming. The pain was...something. Naturally, the only saline solution in the house was packed in the bottom of my duffel bag. As a temporarily blind person, weeping like a small child, the saline was difficult to find. Once I found it, I doused my eye, and the pain started to subside after 10 minutes or so. Today I'm left with a mildly bloodshot eye...
My boyfriend absolutely loved it! He thought it was the perfect gift- the sizes choices and variety were great and he hasn’t had a meal without them lol!
On the classic plan, super great, super tasty. Not just heat but spice. Very happy with the variety and curation. Not one loser in the bunch. One of the easier gift boxes to give to the hothead in your life.
Spot on. A lit of fun, & really well done
I was pleasantly surprised by the 1st box! I ordered for my Husband, and he's in like, other than the Sriracha, lol. The FYM is yum and I don't even do super-hot!
It was really good, and really hot.
This was supposed to be a surprise Father's Day gift. I selected to have the email sent on Father's Day but they sent it early.
I'm so sorry about that, this must be a bug with Cratejoy because we processed your order normally and usually the email doesn't go out until the date specified. We've escalated this to Cratejoy so it doesn't happen again.
It says they ship within one week of placing the order. I ordered on june 1, it is now June 14 and it still hasn’t shipped. They created a label to make it look like it shipped one week after I placed the order, but Usps still hasn’t received the package from the seller. I purchased this for someone’s birthday that was now one week ago. Extremely disappointed.
Terrible because I ordered it, it shipped then never arrived.
Hey Jade - I'm so sorry about that, it looks like your sauce was lost by USPS. We'd be happy to send off a replacement at no extra cost.
I had not received my order and left feedback. I was immediately contacted by the company and they sent me a replacement box by priority mail. I love the choices of hot sauces sent and will definitely re-subscribe. Thank you for taking care of your customers!
Got this for my Dad for Fathers Day as he is a hot sauce aficionado. He loves it so far-Really liked the Reaper Sauce!
Received the first box and LOVED it. Sauce was excellent and we are looking forward to next month's box! Thanks!
My husband loves spicy food and I gave him a 1 year subscription. All the hot sauce bottles come with tasting notes and ideas of how to use them.
Just received my first order and I must say absolutely amazing hot sauces it was worth the wait! It's best to contact them through Facebook by the way!
I bought for my daughter and her fiance. He says" this stuff is the fuck " My daughter assures me that is good. The bonus was it named after a cat and they are cat rescuers.
Pleasantly surprised with how great this has been! Every package has been so tasty and a variety of spice levels.
This was a Christmas gift for my boyfriend! He loves it! The flavor of the first sauce we got was so good with eggs and Mexican food, he just wishes it was a bit hotter. It was the perfect heat for me! Overall this was a great gift!
I bought a 3-month subscription as a birthday gift for my son and he really loved it!
Purchased as a birthday gift and it was very well received.
We love this subscription! I gave it to my husband as a Valentine’s Day gift and it turns out it’s a gift for me too. We’ve loved all of the sauces so far and always look forward to the next one. Best monthly subscription I’ve had!
So good! The hottest one has had great flavor and very spicy!
Only had our first delivery so far but it's so good! This subscription was a gift for my husband for our anniversary and the Extra Hot we received has an amazing flavor that he loves. We are really looking forward to future shipments!