My mom really liked them! She did note that they don't taste as sweet as she thought they might, they taste a little more like peanut butter then candy treats. Still good all the same.
My box was pretty with the bow.. You know it's going to be good.
I enjoyed every single piece. Dark choc is a fav.
Will be ordering more.
Loved the peanut butter cup treats. Very tasty and enjoyed the holiday theme. Looking forward to the flavors to come.
So tasty but I had two of one kind and was missing another flavor as a result.
Everything from them was amazing just don't use cratejoy there a pain to deal with lol but the original cup is my favorite 10/10 will be buying again!
Thank you for your kind words. I just wanted to quickly ask, is the overall rating you left by chance a mistake? We're so glad you enjoyed your cups but the 1 start overall rating does not seem to match your other ratings and kind words. If you are able, it would be greatly appreciated if you could update it to reflect the rest of your review.
Thank you so much! We're so glad we were able to send some Nutty Smiles your way,
This was given as a gift and was enjoyed by my friend. I was a bit disappointed to find that each month featured the same selection with only one being different. That said, my friend said the chocolate and the peanut butter were outstanding in flavor.
I bought a 6 month subscription for my elderly parents for Christmas. They loved it. I would highly recommend these for anyone. I'm jealous they wouldn't share any with me. If you want to support a local awesome business while getting an awesome product delivered on time every time, she's the one to order from. Thanks for the wonderful treats for my parents.
Thank you so much for your kind words! I'm so glad your parents enjoyed their subscription :)
World’s best PB cups!
Thank you thank you thank you!!!!
tasty but they shipped the same flavor every time. that ruined the excitement of subscription.
Thank you so much for your feedback. I'm so sorry to hear you were unsatisfied with your subscription. As our description states, each box will contain a couple of the Cup of the Month and the remainder of the box would be made up of 6 of the remaining flavors we make throughout the year, rotating out a different flavor each month (so one month no PBJ, the next month no Milky Almond, etc). If you would have rather had the Cup of the Month and only 2 or 3 of the other flavors in each box, please let us know. We take your feedback seriously and would love to improve our subscribers' experience. Thank you!
These are delicious! The quality is fantastic. They are unbelievably tasty, go for the bigger box. 8 isn’t enough!
Thank you so much! I'm so glad to hear you enjoyed them :)
Fed Ex delays were the only thing that out a damper
On this purchase. The vendor was right on it and let me
Know what the hold up was. The recipient was OVER THE MOON with the cups once they did get to her.
Not as good as I hoped. The nut butters are super oily so then as soon as you take a bite the filling comes out
I'm so sorry to hear you did not enjoy your cups. We grind and make our peanut butter filling fresh in house and do not add any oil. However, as all orders are filled with freshly made cups, the filling, upon arrival, is definitely on the gooey side (we do not do anything to dehydrate the filling). If you prefer your cups with a firmer PB center, I would recommend keeping them in the fridge and enjoying them chilled or simply letting them age a bit to allow the centers to naturally firm up a bit.
Fantastic! I received this as a gift, and it's been one of the most original and delicious gifts ever.
Thank you so much for your kind words :) So glad they brought some smiles your way
Basic as can be, not worth the price tag
I’m so sorry our Nutty subscription was not to your liking. We take our customer’s feedback seriously and of course want all of our Nutty customers to be happy. We will be reaching out to you via email so that we might continue this discussion and see how we can make it right.
My mom really loved this mother's day gift. This is perfect for any lover of peanut butter and chocolate.
Beautifully packaged! A nice gift for a candy lover.
Maaaan!!! These are great! I'm a
peanut butter cup addict, and these have got to be the best I've tasted. You can taste the quality in these cups. My favorites were the pretzel cup and the apple cup. Definitely worth it!!!!
Delicious, creative, varied, and beautifully packed!
They were FABULOUS !! There just wasn't enough of them. They went really quick. I loved all the different varieties. Can't wait til next month.
These were tasty, but overall found the subscription just ok. Don’t get me wrong, I recommend them. If there was more of a variety it would have been much better. The descriptions didn’t always match what was in the box. It was the same items every month with the exception of 1 rotating flavor.
Wow! These are amazing; I was secretly hoping not to like them because they are pricey but after opening up the box, the presentation was lovely and I had the pretzel one first (wanted sweet & salty) and it has to be one of the best treats I’ve ever had. It’s been an hour, and I’ve gone back for two more. I have to give myself a little credit (only eating half so I can share the other half with b.f.) but these are so delicious. I’m going to have to keep my subscription a little longer :)
These are some special chocolates! Great tasting, and different. Loved them!
The box is adorable and I love how they are packed with ice packs to help keep the sweets not melt! I was hoping for more variety and a bit more sweetness. If you want a not so sweet option then this is great for you!
Hi i got them today very good i will keep them for a while
Fabulous peanut butter cups, exceeded expectations!