Reviews (138)
Great products, Bad colors
Jun 26, 2019
Michelle D.
The four products are fabulous, but the actual colors themselves are not my style and do not go with my skin tone.
The lip liner glides on smoothly, but the dark color looks awful on me.
The lip gloss isn't overly glossy, but the color is too much on the peachy side.
The Lip Monthly lipstick is great. I love the matte finish and how easily it glides on. But again, it's way too pink on me.
The lip balm is just a lip balm. There's not much good or bad to say either way.
Verified Purchase
Hi Michelle,
Before signing up for Lip Monthly via Cratejoy, we have subscribers complete a survey to let us know what shades they prefer.
It looks like you didn't choose your preferred shades so we weren't able to shades that would be suitable for you.
Please email our support team with your preferred shades. The options are: gold, glitter, black, blue, green, purple, orange, brown, nude, berry, red and pink!
Team LM
pretty average
Jul 02, 2019
Ruby T.
there could’ve been a wider variety of colours from the ones i chose while signing up. the lip creme is very sticky and the lip monthly lipstick smells pretty bad. the lip liner has a nice texture though :-)
Verified Purchase
Need options
Jun 26, 2020
Erin M.
You should survey your customers to see what color or kind of lip products they are looking for.
Verified Purchase
Poor quality ptoducts
Jul 31, 2019
Colleen M.
I liked all the colors and the types of products that I received but the quality was poor and I have been charged twice and only received one shipment. The lip liner was hard and difficult to work with and the matte finish I enjoyed the color but the lipstick would not stay on for a longer than an hour. There was one gloss that I will continue to use but the rest of the package Was forgettable.
Verified Purchase
Hi Colleen,
Your first payment in mid-June was for our July bag, which shipped out between the 10th - 15th of July and received shortly after that. Your second payment which we received end of July is for our August bag, which as stated our listing, ships between the 10th - 15th of each month.
Team LM
Not kissable
Jun 02, 2019
Erin M.
I've been getting this subscription box for a couple months now, I really enjoy receiving at but shipping notifications are not given, and I would really like being able to track my order. I've enjoyed the colors that have been sent, but the most recent lipstick I received was terrible. It caked on my lips, making little lipstick balls all over that we're annoying to have on my lips. Even after letting it dry for 10 minutes it still came off when testing it by kissing my arm. If I went to kiss anybody on the cheek or on their lips they would be left bright red! this lipstick is no good.
Verified Purchase
Underwhelming
Oct 17, 2018
Jena B.
I gave this subscription 3 stars because I was felt that the item received were not cohesive. I received a dark purple lipstick that smells like a crayons, a coral lip liner, holographic lip gloss, and a red lip/cheek crayon. It was random. Also, bag is poor quality. It’s made of very cheap fabric compared to something like Ipsy. Not worth it for me.
Verified Purchase
Wrong colors
Aug 03, 2019
Peggy C.
Wrong colors both times. I think I would really enjoy it if I could get them to send anything in the rose family.
Verified Purchase
lip monthly ok
Jan 25, 2019
M
This month in color picks was much better than December picks. I at least liked two of the four colors I got but I still can't see keeping this subscription. I don't know the names of most of the brands and I don't like non matte lipsticks, it get all over you and other people. I love a true matte lipstick.
Verified Purchase
First
Nov 15, 2020
Casey T.
Little disappointed
Verified Purchase
Outdated
Jul 25, 2019
Patricia K.
Better make up subscriptions available. Bag was cheap & items seemed outdated.
Verified Purchase
December 2018
Jan 04, 2019
Brianna N.
I really, really, really wish there was an option to at least choose a color palette (darks, nudes, etc.) because the quality of these products are fantastic and I'm introduced to new brands, but I don't wear the shades that are sent.
Verified Purchase
Hi Brianna,
We totally agree with you! We actually added a survey a few months ago so customers can give us their preferences for shades. This is done during the checkout process.
Unfortunately, we aren't able to add this for anyone that signed up before we had this option.
I'm going to send you an email with the options and you can let me know what you prefer!
Thanks,
Team LM
Nov 29, 2018
Elizabeth J.
Didn't like the blush/gloss and really don't use lip balms. Want more dark colored lipsticks. Just fair
Verified Purchase
Lip Monthly
Feb 20, 2019
Jennifer L.
Love the subscription but hate that you can't do the payment on the first so I'll be canceling tomorrow
Verified Purchase
Nice
Mar 29, 2019
Meena S.
Beautiful some colors are very light but that's fine
Verified Purchase
Oct 30, 2018
Jodi D.
I was super excited to get my first bag but canceled right after I got it. There wasn’t anything in it that I would use at all. Some got colors that looked ok but I received products that were way too “bright.” If even one had been a more natural “wear every day” type of color, I would have kept the subscription. However, I wasn’t out a lot of money to try it. It just didn’t work for me.
Verified Purchase
I was hoping for something more exciting
Apr 01, 2019
Charlotte W.
The package took quite a long time to arrive and by the time I got it the discount code provided for the next month was expired. I chose many colours in my preferences, just not pink or orange, but I only got two very pinky nude lipsticks, a shiny gloss and a brown lip pencil. I was hoping for more exciting colours like blue, green or even just a berry colour. Still nice products just disappointing colours.
Verified Purchase
Disappointing
May 30, 2019
Kelly P.
I received my lip bag a month and a half after purchasing it. Note, i did purchase it after the "receive this month's box" deadline but waiting over a month was ridiculous. When I received it, the contents looked nice. I did not like the shade on any of the products (minus the lip balm of course).
After reading other reviews, I noticed some customers "filled out a survey" before making their selection and I didn't get that option.
Verified Purchase
Hi Kelly,
Our order/shipping schedule, as laid out in the Product Overview of our listing, states that orders ship out between the 10th-15th of each month. Orders must be placed before the last day of the month to receive the following month's bag. There's also an example listed: orders placed in September will receive their first bag in October.
We've also responded to both your emails in a timely manner.
Your first bag will be our June bag as per our shipping structure outlined in our Product Overview section on Cratejoy Marketplace.
Team LM
Ready for my next complete surprise
Jul 02, 2019
Heidi M.
I don't know what to say. The lip balm sent is very nice. It's probably my fave item. I did get a brown eye liner that I'll probably use or gift. Not sure why I would receive that in a lip sub though. Nude lip stick is pretty nice. Can't see it at all on my lips, so it's definitely nude. But the color matte lipstick is absolutely ridiculous and hideous. CORAL. Like a Barbie Video, at that. And lip monthly, I didn't request that for when I signed up. I know for certain because it looks ridiculous on me.
Verified Purchase
It’s cute but cancel option doesn’t work
Nov 22, 2019
Kirstin D.
My mom loves the box! Unfortunately, it was only canceling doesn’t work so now she’s going to be getting a total of 9 months. Fortunately, I love her.
Seller: please cancel.
Verified Purchase
Not for me but price is good.
Dec 02, 2019
Mary A.
The price is the only thing that makes me give as many stars as I did. I do not like the fact that you can not change anything on your order, meaning, if you put down matte red and brown, that's it. Your are stuck with those choices. I purchased what was going to be the first bag for my daughter who has a medium skin tone and looks great with the reds and browns. I am very fair. We joke that I'm really close to being transparent, I'm that light. The reds and browns are a not for me.
Verified Purchase
Not canceling just yet
Sep 16, 2020
Amber J.
I just received my 1st box...super fast shipping but i ordered it for my 13 yr old...not syre what eue shadow has to with lips nor do i know where "clear glitter and pink" translated to bright stripper-esque lipstick but hey im sure i can regift them and make a friend super happy the other 2 items were PERFECT FOR HER and im sure she will love them
Verified Purchase
May 2019 bag
Oct 30, 2018
Tammy D.
The one thing about these bags is the colors are always similar month to month. I would like some different colors. An nix the balm every month. I don't wear them nor like them every single month I'd prefer a face mask or lip mask anything else besides balms...products are good love the liquid lipstick. I'd recommend anyone to try Lip monthly
Verified Purchase
What?
Dec 19, 2018
Kimberly S.
Says this months has been delivered....but with November date? Please send my bag or my $12. Last months bag was nice.
Verified Purchase
Good
May 02, 2019
Christine B.
I liked 2 out of the 4 it was cool gonna try once more to see
Verified Purchase
Eh.
Mar 16, 2019
Mairead L.
This would be a good gift for a preteen or young teen: simple, neutral colors with a liner and top coat. However, I'm a little past the candy pink lipstick phase, and getting two mostly identical shades (and one in a brand I dislike) for my first box was not impressive,