This was a gift for my stepdaughter. She was looking forward to trying new lip products but her first box included mostly other types of makeup. While they seem to be good quality and a good value for the price of the box it definitely wasn't what we expected. I hope future boxes are lip products as advertised
Updating my opinion on Lippie Box. I like it. I think I'll keep it. $19 is maybe a tad too much but it's like a treat for myself. It's still fun to get in the mail and I love most of the things they send. You get to try products from smaller hand-made companies, which is nice. The card inside the box gives you their links, maybe some coupons. And both months I've gotten so far have included a body scrub. It's nice to get one non-lip product. I guess I wouldn't mind one or two Lip Smackers products. I imagine it's hard to put together a box that will suit both older customers like me (30 yrs) and younger girls. I get that this is a smaller company that say, Ipsy or Boxycharm, and I like to support small businesses so I'm going to keep this subcription for a while. 'Til I'm drowning in lip products, I suppose.
My daughter received her first box today. It had a $34 value. Everything included in her box is something she can use. I gave it 4 stars instead of 5 because there was an item missing (I did not include it in the box value). Otherwise, this box was amazing and I am already a fan!