I personally thought the Penguin costume, book and ornament craft were adorable. Penguin feet too! This was the first box which I purchased for my 3 year old granddaughter who loves to read, pretend, dress up and be a princess. My granddaughter did not like the Penguin costume (3 year olds can be a little slow to like something) She doesn’t like black and white. She thought it was for a boy even though I told her that girl Penguins are black and white. She said she loves color and princesses. She agreed to try a box next month 🤞🏼Crossing my fingers that she will think it’s awesome. I personally loved the Penguin and I’m not sure it’s fair to give it 4 stars based on what my granddaughter said. So buy a box you won’t regret it. Such a wonderful concept. I can’t wait to see what is in January’s box. Hopefully a little color ❤️