I got two boxes. The first box, I was not a fan of the book. The 'gifts' were great quality, but also not my style (regiftable though!)
The second box, The book was much more enjoyable, but the gifts were despicable. The first 'gift' was literally a post it note with a string of numbers on it.
Hi Olivia! Thank you so much for your feedback! We typically always include a paper item in our monthly boxes, as frequently letters, photographs, or other paper items are vital to the plot of the novel we've selected and we feel it's important to bring to life for our readers so they feel as though they're in the moment of these scenarios. While these items may not have any monetary value, we hope that the experience of pulling out a slip of paper at the same time as the character creates a value in the experience for you! Additionally, we hope the rest of the gifts were ones you could use and appreciate throughout your daily life! - The...
The concept for this box is really great, but unfortunately the box I received didn't live up to expectations.
The good: As I said, I really like the idea of waiting until certain pages of the book to open a wrapped box. It was exciting, and kept me reading. The best part is that there are little post-it stickies on the specific page to remind you to open your box. That definitely takes a lot of work, and I admire the dedication from the curators!
The bad: The book itself (The Last Piece by Imogen Clark) was terrible. It has a 3.89 rating on GoodReads and I honestly have no idea how it could have achieved that. The prose was extremely pedestrian, the plot was completely predictable, the characters were one-dimensional, one of the main characters was downright unlikable, there was a bizarre twist towards the end of the book that was not explained at all and just accepted as normal by the rest of the characters, and after 2/3 of the book I basically just hate-skimmed it to get to the end. I read like a self-published Kindle free-book by a talented amateur writer who never met an editor.
The gifts in the box were either uninteresting/cheap or only loosely tied to the book, which I think undermined the concept of this box. There was only one thing in the box that I ended up keeping (and it definitely wasn't the book itself).
Overall, a good idea that is lovingly,...
First of all, we loved the subscription! I ordered a three month subscription for my daughter for her birthday but it wouldn’t cancel after MULTIPLE times of me checking and verifying a cancellation. It kept reverting back for some reason. I don’t know if this is a Cratejoy issue or Once upon a Book Clubs. What I do know is I now have a total of $86.98 of unauthorized charges. I was planning to do another three month subscription for her for Christmas but I’m SO upset over this.
Loved the book choice, but wasn’t a fan of some of the extras included. Included a wine opener set (already had one because most adults do), a little tea bag and ceramic tea bag plate (wasn’t sure what it was for, but did like this one because it was cute), what looked like a small binder with a weird clip that was damaged (again, no explanation as to what it was for), and a letter that went with the story, but I struggled to read it due to the light print (plus it was verbatim what was written in the book, so unnecessary). I’m going to cancel my subscription because I didn’t feel like the extras included were worth what I was paying for the subscription box and I have a bookstore in town if I want to buy myself a new book.
I have done 4 of these boxes, and each time I ended up hoping that the next time would be better. It never was. I have enjoyed the book selections, but the gifts...not so much. Which in the end makes it a VERY expensive paperback...approaching $50.00 when factor in shipping. I appreciate the thought that went into the gifts and the presentation, but the gifts are mostly very cheap stuff, like obviously made in China quality, and of the four boxes there is exactly one gift that I liked enough to keep. It does add to the reading experience, and makes it exciting, but ultimately I end up feeling let down. I just wish that the gifts could follow the story AND be something that I would actually use.