I got the 50+pound size and 2 things my dog didn't even have an interest in. The bully sticks ( 2 packages) he ate 1 in less than 5 min. The ones I buy at pet stores or feed and tack stores last for a week or more. Total waste of money and joke of variety.
We're so sorry to hear that you were unhappy with your box! We go to great lengths to curate a box that has a good assortment of products that most dogs will like. That said, every pup has their own preferences and sometimes we miss the mark. We do send different products from month to month, but totally understand if you didn't want to see what the next month had in store if the 1st month wasn't a good fit for your pup.
In terms of the product that your dog ate very quickly, I suspect that that was our Filled Esophagus Stick, rather than a bully stick. The reason that I say that is because the Filled Esophagus Sticks are esophagus on the outside...