Not sure how I feel about this box yet, especially for the price. Maybe if it were only $15 I would rate it higher. The thing is, I bought a past box and the current box.
The past box was nice, although nothing terribly impressive. I did really love the Cover Girl Lipstick - great shade and nice product (July 2016).
But then when I opened my January box, it seems to me it's got discontinued items you find at a job lots or dollar store. The price point they give you is for the full price as if it were new, but the truth is they sell for far less once they are discontinued. I actually went to the Milani and Covergirl websites to see if the products were currently being offered, and they are not. (I work for a national drugstore chain, so I would probably know if these products were current).
I still enjoy the box and will keep subscribing, but so far, I think the value isn't there in the merchandise, and I'm paying for curation.