Product Details

Coley's BAKED Box makes each month a bit sweeter!

Each month you will receive a box filled with freshly baked items, each box will include - 2 Decorated Sugar cookies from our seasonal collection - 1 Gourmet cookie + 1 cookie of the month - 1 Cookie Sammie - 1 Out of this world Brownie - 1 Additional Treat or cookie
  • Seasonal favorites and new flavors each month!
  • Free shipping on all subscriptions
  • a retail value of $40.00
  • Our family recipes to be shared with your family
  • Try a bit of everything BAKED by Coley has to offer

Sneak Peek

Photo of BAKED Box current box February BAKED Box

February BAKED Box

February's BAKED is all about sweet treats for Valentines day! The box includes: 2- Decorated Vanilla Sugar Cookies 2- Sprinkle Sammies 1- Strawberry Crunch Cookie- a strawberry cookie topped with vanilla buttercream and strawberry crunch topping 1- Toffee Chocolate Chip Cookie - a traditional chocolate chip cookie with Toffee Bits for crunch and Dark Chocolate Chips to balance the sweetness. 1- Traditional Brownie 2- Chocolate Dipped Heart Shaped Shortbread

Order by February 25th to get this box!


Customer Questions (7)

1

Q: I wanted to order a subscription for my MOY, I noticed the June box had a Dad cookie. She is a widow and didn’t want a cookie to be triggering. Can we skip a month? Or request 2 of the truck cookiesAsked by Bambi B., December 2022

Baked by Coley answered...December 2022

Great Question! This past year was our first full year of BAKED Box, the past boxes show you what was sent last year. We have learned A LOT, going forward I will not be doing Mothers Day & Fathers Day Boxes. There will not be MOM & DAD cookies for May and June. I understand that doing these cookies may not be as enjoyable or relatable for everyone receiving the boxes. Instead it may be May Flowers for May and Summer Fun boxes for June. Thank you! -Nicole, BAKED by Coley


1

Q: I'm not a fan of chocolate. Can they be replaced with something not chocolate? Asked by Jenni W., November 2022

Baked by Coley answered...November 2022

Thank you for your question, unfortunately the items in the BAKED boxes cannot be substituted. Although I try my best to balance the each box with different flavors, chocolate is used in many of our cookies and brownies/blondies all year long.


1

Q: Do you have a 12 month subscription? I ordered it last year for my friends and they loved it! I just wanted to give it to them again. Will the cookies differ or stay the same?Asked by Tammy B., November 2022

Baked by Coley answered...November 2022

Hi Tammy, Thank you for your question, I am so happy to hear your friends enjoyed their year of BAKED boxes!! I opened the year subscription back up for purchase.
I intend to fill the boxes with the favorites of last year and bring in some new flavors throughout the year.


1

Q: Hello, Do the cookies contain nuts? We have nuts allergy in my household. Thank you!Asked by Aurora R., September 2022

Baked by Coley answered...September 2022

Hi there, usually there is one cookie a month in the box that contains nuts.
Thank you so much for your question.

Reviews (14)

Great box, everything was yimmy

Jan 11, 2023
Verified Purchase
Anne M.
1 Review
Subscribed for 1 month

We were very pleasantly surprised. Everything was delicious and packed well. There was a nice variety. I would get this box again and would highly recommend it.

Lots of interesting and yummy stuff.

Oct 03, 2022
Verified Purchase
Colleen K.
1 Review
Subscribed for 9 days

What fun to receive!!!! I shared most of my box because there wasn’t a lot of chocolate and I’m a chocolate gal! Red velvet cookie was yummy had white chocolate pieces in it. The sweet and salty blonde was good but I’m not a butterscotch fan so I ate some and my friend gobbled up the rest. The items are super fresh and well packaged. Looking forward to my next box!!!! Thank you for offering this fun subscription.

fresh

Sep 21, 2022
Verified Purchase
Amy S.
1 Review
Subscribed for 8 days

fresh and delicious

Homemade aesthetics pro baker skills

Aug 06, 2022
Verified Purchase
Lisa L.
4 Reviews
2 Pictures
Subscribed for 5 days

Just got my first box. Delighted at how well it was packaged and the variety of treats. This baker really has some skills, while retaining that real home made quality. So fun! Haven’t eaten any yet… but I just know they’re going to be delicious.

Exactly what I hoped for

Aug 05, 2022
Verified Purchase
Mona Z.
1 Review
Subscribed for 5 days

Gorgeous and delicious! Though with this dang diabetic blood I could only sample two bites. More tomorrow. Very pleased! Thank you so much!

Delicious sweets

Mar 01, 2022
Verified Purchase
Debora E.
1 Review
1 Picture
Subscribed for 28 days

Once shipped it got here very quickly! Very cute packaging and the sweets were delicious!! My fiance and I really enjoyed the cookies and the sammies. Each item was good and you could tell it was fresh. We got to enjoy them on Valentines day so thank you very much!

Fresh and Delicious

May 09, 2022
Verified Purchase
Angela P.
17 Reviews
1 Picture
7 Helpful
Subscribed for 5 days

This is my first box and I am pleased with everything! They arrived in one piece for starters. They were fresh and delicious too! Can’t wait for the next box😊

Great box!

Apr 29, 2022
Verified Purchase
Arlene W.
1 Review
1 Helpful
Subscribed for 2 months

A great product. I just have to subscribe to this box less often as I would like to keep an eye on my waistline and it is next to impossible to not eat this all up.

Amazing

Apr 20, 2022
Verified Purchase
Nancy B.
1 Review
Subscribed for 11 days

The cookies were absolutely amazing, we thought they were the best and most delicious we’ve ever had. Very excited about keeping this subscription.

Delicious!

Apr 11, 2022
Verified Purchase
Cindy S.
2 Reviews
Subscribed for 25 days

Super cute AND tasty! Love getting these yummy treats delivered to ME!!

Photos from reviews of BAKED Box


Past boxes from BAKED Box

November's BAKED Box

November's BAKED Box

In this box you recieve (2) fall decorated sugar cookies, (2)mini oatmeal sammies, (1) out of this world brownies, (1) gourmet chocolate chip cookie, (1) our famous cranberry white chocolate oatmeal cookies, (1) large rice crispie treat and a sample treat for our upcoming holiday gift boxes, cookie truffles!!

Decembers BAKED Box

Decembers BAKED Box

Decembers Baked Box is here!! Each month a new BAKED Box comes out with an array of goodies from our catalog. This months goodies include: 2- Decorated Sugar Cookies (hot cocoa mug and a christmas tree) 2- Cranberry White Chocolate Blondies topped with a whipped white chocolate frosting and topped with dried cranberries and more white chocolate 2- Red Velvet Mini Sammies with a White Chocolate Frosting in the middle 2- Snickerdoodles and 1- Brownie M&M Cookie 2- Cook

January's BAKED BOX

January's BAKED BOX

HAPPY NEW YEAR!! This months BAKED BOX includes two sugar cookies decorated for celebrating 2022, a caramel toffee brownie, a chewy ginger cookie, white chocolate macadamia nut cookie, our fan favorite Oatmeal sammies (2) and our special addition this month is mini vanilla donuts!

February's BAKED Box

February's BAKED Box

Our February's BAKED Box is all about Valentines Day!! Includes the following: 2) Decorated Sugar Cookies 1) Tuxedo Brownie- out of this world brownie topped with White Chocolate Frosting 1) Red Velvet Gourmet Cookie 1) Sprinkle Cookie 2) Brownie Sammies 1) Strawberry Truffle Crunch Pop - a Strawberry Cookie mixed with white chocolate to create and truffle then dipped in white chocolate and strawberry crunch topping! This box begins shipping on 1/28/22

March BAKED Box

March BAKED Box

March's BAKED Box contains goodies inspired by St. Patrick's Day and includes the following: - Mint Chip Gourmet Cookie: a Mint flavored cookie with chocolate chips and andes mint chips - Chocolate Dipped Shortbread Cookie - Butterscotch Blondie - (2) Sugar Cookie Sammies rolled in rainbow sprinkles - (2) Decorated Sugar Cookies - Chocolate Dipped Oreo The Last day to order this box is 3/24, any subcriptions sign up after that date will receive April's Box

April BAKED Box

April BAKED Box

Our April box is Easter Themed, Includes the following: 2) Decorated Sugar Cookies 1) Brookie Cookie - Half Brownie Cookie & half Chocolate Chip Cookie 1) Soft Sugar Cookie frosted w/ a Strawberry Buttercream Frosting 1) Cosmic Brownie - our traditional brownie topped with fudge frosting and mini M&Ms 2) Lemon Sammies - a Lemon Cookie filled with a Lemon frosting 2) Peanutbutter Eggs

May BAKED Box

May BAKED Box

May's BAKED Box is all about MOMS: 1) Traditional Sugar Cookie 1) Lemon Sugar Cookie (NEW!!) 1) Cranberry White Chocolate Blondie 1) Walnut Chocolate Chunk Cookie 1) Blueberry Cheese Cookie 2) Coffee & Creme Sammies 1) Brownie Sammie (this month's special treat) Please note our special treat is typically chocolate, since we want to avoid melting through the delivery process, the summer months BAKED Box will include an additional cookie or sammie

June BAKED Box

June BAKED Box

The June BAKED Box is the ultimate cookie box for Dad, it includes: 2) Decorated Sugar Cookies 2) Lime Sammies 1) Brown Sugar Heath Candy Cookie 1) Golden Oreo Cookie 1) Rocky Road Cookie 1) Peanut Butter Cookie Blondie

July BAKED Box

July BAKED Box

The July Box is celebrating the Fourth of July and includes: - 2 Decorated Sugar Cookies - 1 M&M Blondie -1 Apple Pie Oatmeal Cookie -1 Strawberry Lemonade Cookie -1 Cherry Sammie -1 Berry Sammie -1 Coconut cream Sammie

August BAKED Box

August BAKED Box

Our August BAKED Box theme is ICECREAM! a fun way to end the month boxes! Each cookie is based off popular icecream flavors! The August BAKED Box includes: 2- Decorated Vanilla Butter Sugar Cookies 1- Neapolitan Cookie 1- Butter Pecan Cookie 1- Mocha Almond Cookie 1- Pistachio Sammie 1- Chocolate Chip Sammie 1- Cookies n Creme Blondie

September BAKED Box

September BAKED Box

The September BAKED Box is all about getting ready for leaves turning and Football Season! Lets get ready for fall! this box includes 1- Vanilla Butter Decorated Sugar Cookie 1- Fall Spice Decorated Sugar Cookie 1- Cinnamon Roll Cookie 1- Red Velvet White Chocolate Chip Cookie 1- Pumpkin Cheesecake Cookie 2- Oatmeal Sammies 1- Sweet & Salty Blondie (our traditional blondie with chocolate chips, caramel bits & pretzels!)

October BAKED Box

October BAKED Box

Happy Halloween!! Octobers box is about celebrating and includes: 1- Triple Chocolate Brownie - a dark chocolate brownie with milk chocolate and white chocolate chips 1- Sprinkle Cookie 1- Peanut butter Lovers Cookie - a thick peanut butter cookie stuffed with reeces cups 1- Monster Cookie - oats, peanut butter, m&ms and chocolate chips!! 2- Brownie Sammies 2- Decorated sugar cookies


Customers who bought this also bought...

Baked by Coley appears in these collections...


Ships Fast

BAKED Box

by Baked by Coley
Preferred Seller
Fresh BAKED goodies shipped to your door each month!

Last Minute Gift? No worries.
Download and print this note to let them know their gift is on the way.

Shipping Policy
First box ships within 5 business days of your order
Following boxes the 27th-1st of the month
Renews monthly on the 11th
We expect you to receive your boxes within the first week of the month The current box is available till the 25th of each month, if you purchase after...
Cancellation & Refund Policy

Questions for Baked by Coley?