Comic Mystery Box
by Comic Mystery Box$31.00/ month
Buying OptionsReviews (117)
IMO-Definitely worth it!
May 13, 2023
Josh
The description of what's being offered is very accurate. I emailed the seller about my preferences for the comics I wanted and most of those requests were fulfilled. The packing was a little beat up, so I'm not sure if that had something to do with some comic book pages being slightly bent on the ends of the pages and others having some spine ticks, (Could have happened while being shipped to me) but overall I'm pretty happy with what I got for my money! The shipping was fast as well. Will be ordering again sometime in the near future, thank you!
Verified Purchase
Great!
Yesterday
John C.
Great! Great! Great!
Verified Purchase
Great Product, Very Poor Delivery
May 23, 2023
Reece K.
This is a great idea for a subscription box, but the follow through makes it not worth the hassle. I ordered this in December and received my 1st box right away. Perfect. From that point forward, I had to reach out and request the next box. Communication with the vendor led to being advised that "...I am really busy" and "Email me when you are ready for your next box." I don't want to think about my order, I just want to get it as scheduled. Anyway, I paid for 6 months and just now received my 3rd box. I have asked the vendor to simply send me the rest of my order and have gotten nothing in response I have zero hope that I will ever see the rest of my order. I have given up. My recommendation is to not use this vendor.
Verified Purchase
My comic book mystery box
Mar 27, 2023
Joey H.
It came in about 3 different boxes and in plastic so it was definitely well protected. Did have a lil problem with shipping with it getting sent back but they got ahold of me an figured it out. After that got the package pretty quick.
Verified Purchase
Not Good for an Experienced Comic Fan
Apr 07, 2023
Nicole F.
Not happy. There were shipping issues with all 3 boxes received. I had to message the seller because he sent the first box right away but boxes 2 and 3 took months to be shipped.
I got a three-month gift subscription for my husband for Christmas. He is a serious comic book fan and knows a lot about what he’s looking at. This is his review:
Multiple repeat books in all three boxes received. No minor keys were sent and got sent a few 2nd prints. Nothing “vintage” was sent even though it was advertised - books were not older than 80s-90s, and the 90s books sent were ones severely overprinted. The value of books received was also not as advertised. This is not worth fulfilling after subscription is over.
Verified Purchase
Great box for a starting comics reader
Jan 24, 2023
Khaezarn
Received lots of great comics and options to read, even helped me discover some I didn't know existed.
The comics arrive well packaged and protected, I'm very happy and hope to continue this subscription for a long time to come!
Verified Purchase
BEST COMIC COMPANY EVER
Jan 12, 2023
Sebastien R.
Everytime i get these packages they are perfect. Boxing is clean, comics are damaged at all. Will continue to purchase
Verified Purchase
Great comics
Oct 01, 2022
Justen M.
Love the comics that I got can’t wait to see what I get next
Verified Purchase
Monthly comic box
Sep 13, 2022
Todd W.
Good overall, I like the personal newsletter each month.
Verified Purchase
Love this mystery box
Jul 23, 2022
Amber S.
Amazing blend of comics. Seller puts a lot of thought into each box and you get big name comics.
Amazing value
Jul 23, 2022
Malala L.
Fantastic value and packaged with care.
Verified Purchase
Best comic mystery box
Jun 19, 2022
Megan C.
I absolutely loved this box! I asked for specific characters and I got them. Also fast shipping. I got over what I paid for. Thank you so much, I will be purchasing again in the future!
Verified Purchase
Love it
Jul 15, 2022
Andrea D.
Great picks, listened to my suggestions
Verified Purchase
Let Down - buyer beware
Jun 23, 2022
Megan B.
I purchased a 3 month subscription for my husband for Valentines Day, he loves comic books. He received his first box and really enjoyed the comics that he received. He also received his second box. The third box he has yet to receive and when I check my orders it states preparing order. While my husband enjoyed the two boxes that he received, he keeps asking me when the third box is going to come and asking me am I sure that I did a 3 month subscription. I cannot recommend purchasing from this company even with my husband being happy with the first two boxes. I would like to think that it is an oversight on the companies behalf but, until my husband receives what I paid for, I cannot in good faith recommend this to anyone.
Verified Purchase
Best Comic Mystery Box I've Found
Apr 12, 2022
Timothy M.
At first I was a bit disappointed that the comics were not bagged and boarded, BUT the condition of these books are STILL TOP QUALITY. I have only had two boxes so far, but they are fantastic. There are other more expensive comic mystery boxes out there that offer way less. This is quality AND quantity in one. We did an unboxing on our Youtube channel at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9EQxG7ckG1k and you can see how great everything is about this box.
Verified Purchase
Comic book shipment
May 31, 2022
Justin H.
everything was fine , I enjoyed the selection and the delivery was on schedule
Mystery comics did not disappoint.
Apr 09, 2022
Scott B.
Extremely happy with my comic mystery box purchase. Have the 15 for $30 subscription. I was able to request mostly Marvel and that’s exactly what they sent. Great mix of #1’s, 90’s, 2000’s and currents. Value was about twice what I paid.
Verified Purchase
Mystery Comic Box
May 02, 2022
Garrett R.
was awesome and team is great and responsive
Verified Purchase
Could be better
May 25, 2022
Dan O.
I liked my first box a little better than this one. Had more main characters from marvel and dc. I prefer marvel a little more to DC. This box had more secondary character and independent comics than I would have preferred to receive.
Verified Purchase
Issues Made Right
May 08, 2022
Adriana G.
**EDIT: After I posted my review, I received an email regarding my order. I was told they would ship the third box plus one for free because of the issues I had. I'm impressed with this response and thankful they saw my review and made moves to fix the issue. They quickly made the right the issue and that is great customer service. (I'm going to leave my original review as it stands as it shows the full experience.)**
I bought this for my nephew as a Christmas gift because he loves comics. He was happy with the first box, which was delivered on time. The second box wasn't delivered until I contacted the company and asked where it was. They said there was an "error on their end and they had immediately sent the second box" and "I could request the third box to be shipped at any time". I immediately requested the third box be shipped because, at that point, it was well past when the box should have been delivered. That was more than a month ago and I have heard NOTHING. I am incredibly disappointed and will absolutely NOT be ordering from them in the future. Buyer Beware - you may not get what you paid for!!
Verified Purchase
Which Came First? A Nudge or Shipping?
Mar 26, 2022
Martin M.
My review is mixed. Although I am thankful for the gift and for receiving comics, I did feel a bit put out when I had to inquire from the distributor when the next crate would come. Within hours after my inquiry, I received notice of shipping information. Is it a coincidence that my email and the shipping confirmation came within hours of each other? Maybe. Maybe not.
I have one more monthly distribution from Cratejoy. I am hopeful that I will not have to prompt a delivery with an email.
Worth every penny.
Mar 19, 2022
Christopher J.
Great comics, and the communication and service is fantastic.
Verified Purchase
Good
Mar 14, 2022
Branden M.
Very good, on time and friendly.
Verified Purchase
Comic lover approved!
Jan 30, 2022
Samantha S.
Got this for my husband for Christmas and he loved it!! Thoughtfully curated with some number one issues that sparked his interest in new series which h us cool. Great quality comics in fantastic condition.
Verified Purchase
5 stars
Jan 25, 2022
Alan B.
I am so excited to be able to get magazines in such pristine condition and various titles/wriers/artists.