Rachel, we’re sorry you were disappointed. In reviewing your account, I see that you specifically selected the auto-renewing gift option, something that was confirmed in your order submission and email receipt and then again when the subscription renewed. We would have gladly sent a refund and cancelled the shipments had you reached out to us after receiving the renewal notification email, but we never heard from you until 5 weeks later, after the merchandise had already been received by the recipient. We’ve gone ahead and cancelled the remaining 2 shipments and sent a refund for these.

Finders Seekers is a small, family-owned business that operates with highest level of integrity and customer service. Kristen submitted 2 separate orders on 2 separate days, so we shipped 2 separate boxes. Both arrived ahead of schedule and as promised. When Kristen emailed us about it, we offered to send a replacement box that wasn't a duplicate, free of charge or have the customer return the box for a refund. She declined both offers.

Jessica, I'm sorry about the shipping delay for your first box. We were able to get your box in the mail ahead of schedule, but because of COVID delays and the holiday rush, international shipping just took longer in December, something completely out of our control unfortunately. Your other two boxes were shipped ahead of schedule and arrived in a timely manner, once the holidays were over. Our puzzles are designed for adults and we don't get the feedback often that they are too easy. The content is always family-friendly (no murders or violence), but the puzzles are difficult. As you stated, the use of clues and answers does make it easy to solve the puzzles within seconds if you peek at those.

I'm sorry you thought our mystery was too easy. Our puzzles are designed for adults and range from moderate to difficult skill level. It takes most of our subscribers 1.5 - 3 hours to complete. If you use the hints, this makes it for a quicker play though. But I'm glad that you appreciate the quality and design of our materials. A lot of effort and thought goes into each box. We appreciate you giving us a try!

Hi Hannah! I'm so sorry that you haven't received your box yet. Looking at the tracking, it seems that it might have been lost in the post office's holiday shuffle. No worries, we will put a new box in the mail for you right away. If after receiving your first box you decide you don't want your account to renew, let us know and we will send a refund.

Laura, I’m sorry you’re having a hard time canceling. We have several easy options to do so. If you log into your Cratejoy account or Finders Seekers account there is a button that says "Cancel Subscription” or you can always email us. I looked further into your account and see that you purchased a one-time gift subscription, so it was not a renewing subscription and did not need to be cancelled. Perhaps that’s where the confusion was. We’re always happy to assist and respond within 24 hours of any inquiry sent to us.