Jessies-Nutty-Cups

Handcrafted Peanut Butter Cups sent directly to your door!

Loading options...
Plans as low as $16.00 / month
Shipping & Renewal Information
  • Upon receiving your order, we'll ship within 6 business days via USPS Priority, FedEx 2-day or UPS Ground, depending on the destination. We'll contact you if we are concerned about melting due to extreme temps. We can't give refunds for orders that melt due to warm weather. Please contact us with questions.
  • Only ships within United States
  • Subscriptions automatically renew. Cancel anytime
Nutty Subscription - Get your Monthly Nutty Fix
A subscription box for anyone who loves chocolate and peanut butter. Jessie's Nutty Cups are handcrafted peanut butter cups (and occasional almond butter cups) that come in a variety of delicious flavors such as Dark Sea Salt, PBJ and Oreo. We make our own nut butter and use Belgian chocolate for these wonderfully Nutty morsels.
  • Each month your box will include an assortment of Nutty Cups and our special Cup of the Month!
  • Choose from an assorted box of 8 or 15 Nutty Cups!
  • Made to order, you're guaranteed only the freshest peanut butter cups.
  • We make our own peanut butter and put together each cup by hand making certain your order is the best it can be.
  • Makes for the perfect gift for yourself or others!

Sneak Peek

Photo of undefined current box Who's ready for a Nutty Sprinkle Surprise!

Who's ready for a Nutty Sprinkle Surprise!

It’s our classic Nutty Cup but with a bit of a surprise explosion! Milk or dark Belgian chocolate surrounds our gooey PB filling and is topped with all natural sprinkles in the colors of the rainbow. Take a bite and find an extra sprinkle surprise! It's a treat you will go absolutely Nutty for and will be mixed in with a variety of 6 of our 7 signature flavors.

Order by June 30th to get this box!

Questions

1

Q: How do you ship these in the summer? Do you use any cold packs or anything, since you don't refund for melted orders?Asked by Cheryl W., May 2021

Jessies-Nutty-Cups answered...May 2021

We always ship in insulated bubble pouches and in the summer we add ice packs. We check the weather of all destinations on the estimated day of arrival and add either 1 or 2 ice packs accordingly. For orders headed to locations where the temperatures are 90+, we reach out to the buyer to see if they would like to risk shipping or hold until temps are back down a bit.


1

Q: Can you pause a subscription for when you're out of town? Asked by Heidi H., April 2021

Jessies-Nutty-Cups answered...April 2021

Sure! Just email us at orders @ jessiesnuttycups dot com to let us know the details and we’ll take care of the rest ☺️


1

Q: How the heck do I cancel the subscription? I’ve been on both Cratejoy and the vendors sites and can’t see a way to end the subscription. I had signed up for 1 delivery. VERY FRUSTRATING Asked by Mary V., March 2021

Jessies-Nutty-Cups answered...March 2021

Hi Mary,
I am very sorry about this. At checkout there is a place where you specify whether or not you wish for the subscription to renew. It's possible that that was accidentally checked to renew. I just checked your account and it does appear it has already been canceled. I'm sorry for any confusion!


1

Q: when are they shipped each month? If I got ordered mine on the 21st of Dec. will it also come near the same time in January?Asked by Sara D., December 2020

Jessies-Nutty-Cups answered...December 2020

That is exactly right :) If the order was made on say the 15th of Dec, the next box will ship within 5 business days of Jan 15th, and so on.

Jessies-Nutty-Cups reviewsReviews

Write a Review
20 reviews

Buy Them Now!!!!

May 27, 2021
David B.
1 Review
Subscribed for 5 months
Overall
Shipping
Quality
Curation

I bought a 6 month subscription for my elderly parents for Christmas. They loved it. I would highly recommend these for anyone. I'm jealous they wouldn't share any with me. If you want to support a local awesome business while getting an awesome product delivered on time every time, she's the one to order from. Thanks for the wonderful treats for my parents.

Verified Purchase
Jessies-Nutty-Cups said...Jun 03, 2021

Thank you so much for your kind words! I'm so glad your parents enjoyed their subscription :)

So good!

May 07, 2021
Meghan C.
1 Review
Subscribed for 2 years
Overall
Shipping
Quality
Curation

World’s best PB cups!

Verified Purchase
Jessies-Nutty-Cups said...Jun 03, 2021

Thank you thank you thank you!!!!

Even better than you think

Mar 08, 2021
Rachel M.
3 Reviews
Subscribed for 2 months
Overall
Shipping
Quality
Curation

These are delicious! The quality is fantastic. They are unbelievably tasty, go for the bigger box. 8 isn’t enough!

Verified Purchase
Jessies-Nutty-Cups said...Mar 27, 2021

Thank you so much! I'm so glad to hear you enjoyed them :)

Yummy

Mar 05, 2021
Mary V.
1 Review
Subscribed for 15 days
Overall
Shipping
Quality
Curation

Fed Ex delays were the only thing that out a damper
On this purchase. The vendor was right on it and let me
Know what the hold up was. The recipient was OVER THE MOON with the cups once they did get to her.

Verified Purchase

mandy

Jan 21, 2021
Chris M.
1 Review
Subscribed for 1 month
Overall
Shipping
Quality
Curation

Fantastic! I received this as a gift, and it's been one of the most original and delicious gifts ever.

Verified Purchase
Jessies-Nutty-Cups said...Mar 27, 2021

Thank you so much for your kind words :) So glad they brought some smiles your way

Fantastic gift!

Jan 06, 2021
Caroline B.
2 Reviews
Subscribed for 3 months
Overall
Shipping
Quality
Curation

My mom really loved this mother's day gift. This is perfect for any lover of peanut butter and chocolate.

Verified Purchase

Great gift

Dec 26, 2020
Jennifer B.
1 Review
Subscribed for 11 days
Overall
Shipping
Quality

Beautifully packaged! A nice gift for a candy lover.

Verified Purchase

Wow.. just wow

Apr 18, 2020
Brandi W.
2 Reviews
1 Picture
Subscribed for 9 days
Overall
Shipping
Quality
Curation

Wow! These are amazing; I was secretly hoping not to like them because they are pricey but after opening up the box, the presentation was lovely and I had the pretzel one first (wanted sweet & salty) and it has to be one of the best treats I’ve ever had. It’s been an hour, and I’ve gone back for two more. I have to give myself a little credit (only eating half so I can share the other half with b.f.) but these are so delicious. I’m going to have to keep my subscription a little longer :)

Verified Purchase

no variety

May 27, 2021
Tom B.
1 Review
Subscribed for 5 months
Overall

tasty but they shipped the same flavor every time. that ruined the excitement of subscription.

Verified Purchase
Jessies-Nutty-Cups said...May 27, 2021

Thank you so much for your feedback. I'm so sorry to hear you were unsatisfied with your subscription. As our description states, each box will contain a couple of the Cup of the Month and the remainder of the box would be made up of 6 of the remaining flavors we make throughout the year, rotating out a different flavor each month (so one month no PBJ, the next month no Milky Almond, etc). If you would have rather had the Cup of the Month and only 2 or 3 of the other flavors in each box, please let us know. We take your feedback seriously and would love to improve our subscribers' experience. Thank you!

Kind of Disappointed

Mar 26, 2021
Andrea J.
1 Review
Subscribed for 7 days
Overall
Shipping
Quality
Curation

Not as good as I hoped. The nut butters are super oily so then as soon as you take a bite the filling comes out

Verified Purchase
Jessies-Nutty-Cups said...Mar 27, 2021

I'm so sorry to hear you did not enjoy your cups. We grind and make our peanut butter filling fresh in house and do not add any oil. However, as all orders are filled with freshly made cups, the filling, upon arrival, is definitely on the gooey side (we do not do anything to dehydrate the filling). If you prefer your cups with a firmer PB center, I would recommend keeping them in the fridge and enjoying them chilled or simply letting them age a bit to allow the centers to naturally firm up a bit.

Photos from reviews of Jessies-Nutty-Cups

Past boxes from Jessies-Nutty-Cups

July 2018

July 2018

Flavor of the Month: The Nutty S'More Cup Also included Original, Nutty Oreo, Dark Sea Salt, Pretzel, Choco-Hazelnutty and PBJ

CocoNutty

CocoNutty

The CocoNutty Cup! Shredded Coconut enveloped in peanut butter sandwiched between smooth dark chocolate. Every bite is a little taste of paradise. It's a treat you will go absolutely Nutty for and will be mixed in with a variety of 6 of our signature flavors.

May 2018

May 2018

Flavor of the Month: The Nutty Popcorn Cup Also included Original, Nutty Oreo, Dark Sea Salt, Pretzel, Choco-Hazelnutty and PBJ

October - Nutty Apple Spice Cups!

October - Nutty Apple Spice Cups!

This month we're diving head first into fall! Along with some of our stock flavors, our Nutty Box of the Month will include Jessie's Nutty Apple Spice Cups. With delectable apple butter and Jessie's creamy peanut butter in the center, this dark chocolate cup provides all the autumnal goodness you could ask for. Plus it's topped with a sprinkle of granola, so you get just the right amount of crunch.

November  - Nutty Pumpkin Spice Cups!

November - Nutty Pumpkin Spice Cups!

Whats better for November than Pumpkin Spice?!?! This month your Nutty Assortment will include our Nutty Pumpkin Spice Cups. A dollop of Pumpkin filling, accented by our very own Almond Butter and surrounded with Dark Chocolate. This little morsel encompasses all the tastes of fall and is basically like Pumpkin Pie but in Nutty Cup form! It's a treat you will go absolutely Nutty for and will be mixed in with a variety of 6 of our other stock flavors.

December 2019

December 2019

We're getting festive with our Nutty Peppermint Cups which will be included in this month's box subscription box. Our Nutty Peppermint Cups are made up of Jessie's creamy rich peanut butter, encased in smooth dark chocolate topped off with crumbled peppermint. These will be mixed in with a variety of 6 of our other stock flavors... this box truly is the perfect holiday treat!

January 2020

January 2020

Start the New Year with a delicious treat just for you. This month's box will include our January flavor of the month, the Nutty Cookie Cup! Deliciously smooth Belgian Milk Chocolate surrounds scrumdillyumptious Speculoos cookie butter and Jessie's delectable peanut butter and is topped with Speculoos Cookie Crumble. These will be mixed in with a variety of 6 of our other stock flavors... This Nutty delight makes for a perfect pick me up any time of the day or night.

February 2020

February 2020

It's that time of year where you tell your Nutty love just how special they are! This months box will include our special Nutty Honey Cup. It’s hard to argue with the combination of PB and Honey, so we're embracing it! This cup is filled with our special PB and a dollop of pure honey, surrounded by dark chocolate and topped with handmade honeycomb. It's a treat your Honey will go absolutely Nutty for and will be mixed in with a variety of 6 of our other stock flavors.

Elvis is getting Nutty!

Elvis is getting Nutty!

This months box will include our special Nutty Elvis Cup. This cup is filled with a delectable banana peanut butter and surrounded by dark chocolate and topped with a delightful banana chip. It's a treat you will go absolutely Nutty for and will be mixed in with a variety of 6 of our other stock flavors.

Nutty Brownie Caramel Cups!

Nutty Brownie Caramel Cups!

This months box will include our delectable Nutty Brownie Caramel Cup. Inside the Milk Chocolate shell you'll find Jessie's delectable peanut butter mixed with Little Red Kitchen’s amazing brownies and a gooey caramel center. Finish that off with a bit more brownie crumble on top and you have one of the most delicious peanut butter cup variations possible. It's a treat you will go absolutely Nutty for and will be mixed in with a variety of 6 of our signature flavors.

S'more Nutty Please!

S'more Nutty Please!

This months box will leave you wanting more... cause it includes our Nutty S'more Cup! Artisanal Vanilla Bean Marshmallow and Jessie's delectable peanut butter are surrounded by Belgian Milk and sandwiched between graham cracker crumble. The perfect rendition of everyone's favorite camp fire dessert! It's a treat you will go absolutely Nutty for and will be mixed in with a variety of 6 of our other stock flavors.

How about a Nutty Coffee Cup?

How about a Nutty Coffee Cup?

This months box will include our incredibly delicious Nutty Coffee Cup, We've taken our amazing peanut butter filling and added real, freshly ground coffee beans for a touch of flavor and a bit of crunch. Surround that with Belgian milk chocolate and you've got yourself the perfect, 2-bite, pick me up! It's a treat you will go absolutely Nutty for and will be mixed in with a variety of 6 of our other stock flavors.

Subscribe Now