Product Details

Tell us what you love & we'll deliver.

We rescue beloved books (vetted by our pro book lovers) and give them a new home in your collection. Tell us your top 3 favorite plot points/genres and we'll send a book picked just for you, wrapped and adorned with hand-written clues. Each book comes with a free bookmark and sticker. Your first shipment is sent within 5 days of your order.
  • Each book comes lovingly wrapped and adorned with hand-written clues.
  • Each book comes with a FREE bookmark and sticker!
  • Each book is hand-picked based on your favorite plot points/genres.
  • Your first package ships within 7 days of your order date!

Customer Questions (3)


Q: You only send one book per month? Asked by Amy M., December 2022

Pick Your Plot answered...December 2022

Hi Amy!
Yes, we send one book per month.


Q: are your books paperbacks or hardbacksAsked by Tammie T., December 2022

Pick Your Plot answered...December 2022

Thanks for the question! We have both paperbacks and hardbacks. Most of our books are paperback. We send a survey after you sign up to get more acquainted with your likes and dislikes and if you prefer one or the other you can let us know and we’ll make sure to only send what you prefer.


Q: Do you have a category for more literary fiction as opposed to rom-coms or genre fiction?Asked by Kathryn D., January 2023

No answers yet! Be the first to help by adding an answer below.

Reviews (10)

Recieved same book twice otherwise love

Mar 23, 2023
Verified Purchase
Brittany P.
1 Review
Subscribed for 3 months

I got this as a gift for my best friend, she got the same book 2 months in a row.

First box

Mar 23, 2023
Verified Purchase
Elizabeth D.
1 Review
Subscribed for 17 days

Love the book mark and stickers, the book is definitely different from what I usually read but I will definitely give it a go!

Pick Your Plot-Horror

Apr 28, 2023
Verified Purchase
Steph L.
1 Review
Subscribed for 2 months

Unfortunately the book came with the wrapping paper torn off. Not sure what happened there. I’d never heard of the book, but seems interesting. Thanks!

Review - 3 month subscriptiong

Apr 21, 2023
Verified Purchase
Michelle S.
1 Review
Subscribed for 3 months

I bought the three-month one subscription, and I didn't have problems with the books exactly, they were a little worn and a bit older than I was expecting but the advertisement on this literally says “Each book comes with a FREE bookmark and sticker! In the three months I received it, I got exactly 0 stickers and 0 bookmarks. So, I cancelled, due to the wear and tear on the older books and the lack of the full promised subscription.

Pick Your Plot said...Apr 22, 2023

Hi Michelle,
Thanks for reaching out. I’m glad you’ve been enjoying your books. Each book is hand picked by our staff and we try to make sure all of the books are in fairly good condition. We put the stickers and bookmarks just inside the cover of the book inside the wrapping paper with the clues written on it. We double check each book before wrapping it to make sure we haven't forgotten the cute bookmarks and stickers. If that is the case and you have not received them, please email us and we would be happy to send you some stickers and bookmarks. Happy Reading!

Good Choice

Mar 08, 2023
Verified Purchase
Cecelia S.
1 Review
Subscribed for 16 days

Loved getting my first book! Hoping to keep expanding my library!

pick your plot box

Mar 26, 2023
Verified Purchase
Caroline K.
1 Review
Subscribed for 15 days

there should be more than 1 book in the box if i’m paying $16.

Pick Your Plot said...Mar 26, 2023

Hi Caroline,
Thanks for taking the time to leave a review. There is nowhere on our shop or listing on Cratejoy that says you would receive more than one book for the $14.99 that you paid for your subscription. This information would have been readily available before purchasing. The $14.99 covers our cost for our labor (we spend quite a bit of our time searching for the perfect books that fit into the chosen genres), the books, shipping, stickers, bookmarks and shipping materials. Thanks for giving us a try. Happy Reading.

Alice’s Adventures in wonderland

Feb 23, 2023
Verified Purchase
Madison T.
1 Review
2 Pictures
Subscribed for 2 months

As an adult reader, I expect to receive books that are curated towards adults. When I receive this book I actually laughed. This is a child’s book. Something that my ten year old niece would enjoy. But as someone who is paying for this monthly I expect better. The ONLY book I have liked since started this subscription was the first book I received. After that the two I’ve gotten haven’t been great. It honestly feels like the person who picked this, did it very last minute and just grabbed a book without even paying attention to what it was and who it was being sent to.

Pick Your Plot said...Mar 21, 2023

Thanks so much for taking time out of your day to leave a review and give some constructive criticism. I am so sorry to hear that you did not enjoy your book pick this month. We have you down in our records as wanting YA Fiction, Magic & Fantasy. In the form you filled out you also marked that you did not want to receive any Adult Fiction books. Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland is classified as Middle Grade/YA, Magic, and Fantasy and is a great classic work not only for children but also for adults ever since its publication in 1865. This was definitely not a last minute choice, but we should have been more careful in sending books that can also...

Don't know

Feb 01, 2023
Verified Purchase
Kathryn M.
2 Reviews
2 Helpful
Subscribed for 29 days

I have not received this box and wrote that it had not received it and have yet to hear from the company. Until I get this already paid for box, my review is 100% thumbs down. When I looked up the tracker number, it said it had been delivered. Not so!

Pick Your Plot said...Feb 01, 2023

Hi Kathryn. We emailed you back right away after you emailed us yesterday 1/30. It could be in your spam folder, so definitely check there. I’ll email it to you again and leave my response here. Also, I did just want to add that there is nothing we can do as a company besides replace your shipment if USPS marks it delivered and you haven’t received it. That is something you’d need to speak to USPS about. We did, however, already send you out a brand new book yesterday and we updated the tracking number in your account. Here was the email I sent to you yesterday after your first email to us: Monday 1/30 1:45 pm MST
Hi Kathryn,
I’m so sorry to...

my box

Dec 25, 2022
Verified Purchase
Tammie T.
11 Reviews
2 Helpful
Subscribed for 21 days

loved the book and the book mark

Perfect Subscription

Dec 20, 2022
Verified Purchase
Peggy K.
32 Reviews
1 Picture
7 Helpful
Subscribed for 24 days

The book was perfect. Thank you

Photos from reviews of Pick Your Plot

Customers who bought this also bought...

Pick Your Plot was featured in these articles…

Pick Your Plot appears in these collections...


Pick Your Plot

by Pick Your Plot
We rescue beloved books and give them a new home in your collection. Tell us your top 3 favorite plot points/genre's and we'll send you a book picked just for you!

Last Minute Gift? No worries.
Download and print this note to let them know their gift is on the way.

Order by June 10th and get it by Father’s Day

Shipping Policy
Orders placed today ship by July 1
Following shipments are sent by the 15th of the month.
Renews monthly on the 1st
Your package ships by the 15th of the month, every month.
Cancellation & Refund Policy

Questions for Pick Your Plot?