The items all appeared to be okay with the exception of the eyeliner. The entire eyeliner color fell right out of the pencil that it was in. This was my first eyescream box. I canceled my subscription.
I am so sorry to hear that you were upset with your first box! Please email us with pictures and we can of course send you a replacement. All items are brand new and directly from the manufacturers. We appreciate you giving our box a try.
Stay Safe <3