The best grilling and BBQ goods curated by a certified, award-winning Pitmaster

Plans as low as $24.99 / month

Grill Masters Club reviewsReviews

Write a Review

Not a great value. Could leave out mesqu

Jul 15, 2019
Ericka P.
1 Review
5 Helpful Votes
Subscribed for 17 days
Overall
Shipping
Quality
Curation

I hate to say anything negative, but this was an expensive gift and disappointing. Even after a coupon it’s expensive. I gifted my honey this box for Fathers Day surprise but he was not excited. He was bummed to find mesquite chips as he uses his gas bbq grill religiously. It had a red sauce and a white sauce(BBQ) but red sauce tasted like plain ketchup. I really was not impressed. He used the Sweet Slobba rub the most. He said he would rather not order again. Also was a delay in shipping and it came after the holiday. I didn’t care. He didn’t like waiting and I had to contact them.

Verified Purchase

It was a great birthday idea...

May 11, 2017
Dawn P.
1 Review
1 Helpful Vote
Subscribed for 6 months
Overall

I got this for my husband for his birthday - for 6 months. It's a great idea, but as far as the contents of the box- it's lacking.
The first box arrived and I was excited watching my husband opening it, then thought...'that's it?'
The picture on the website probably has at least 4 months worth of box content. Don't get me wrong, The items are good, but 2 bottles of sauce, 1packet of rub, and 1 tin of something else was not what I expected.

Verified Purchase

Crate = 8x10 box

Jan 17, 2017
Susan G.
1 Review
Subscribed for 6 months
Overall

I was very disappointed in the size and amount of products in the "crate". The products looked good but I expected more for the price. The premise of cratejoy is a good one but I expected more like the picture in the ad.

Verified Purchase
Buying Options