Best Ipsy Alternatives for Makeup Enthusiasts

Updated by Brittany Vincent

Love makeup and beauty products? Never quite sure what you want to buy to add to your collection? A makeup subscription box is the perfect thing for you. To that end, Ipsy is a great go-to for cosmetics lovers, but if you want to see what else is out there, you've got plenty to choose from. That's why you should consider trying out some unique Ipsy alternatives, and we've got plenty of picks for you to choose from.

While Ipsy offers a personalized experience, other beauty boxes at Cratejoy such as Slay Glam Box , take customization a step further by allowing subscribers to make color selections on their social media pages. This way, you can have even more control over the items you receive each month.

Why You Should Explore Ipsy Alternatives

Another reason to explore Ipsy alternatives is to discover lesser-known or indie brands that might not be featured in Ipsy's lineup. For example, EYESCREAM Beauty Box offers a delightful mix of full-size products from top brands in the industry, as well as hidden gems that you might not encounter otherwise. By subscribing to an alternative box, you can expand your beauty horizons and uncover new favorites that become staples in your routine.

Additionally, some Ipsy alternatives may focus on specific aspects of beauty, such as skincare, makeup application tools, or even fashion. These niche boxes can complement your existing beauty routine, giving you the opportunity to dive deeper into the world of cosmetics and personal care.

Bottom line? Trying out Ipsy alternatives can be a fun way to inject some variety into your monthly unboxing experience. With each new box, you'll look forward to discovering an assortment of products that push your creative boundaries. What is makeup without trying something new, after all?

Be sure to check out some of our favorite Ipsy alternatives below.

Monthly Slay Glam Box

Monthly Slay Glam Box

From $19.58 per box
Buy Now

Shipping: We will ship your box between the 6th and 25th of each month customer service is available to assist you with quick responses.

EYESCREAM Beauty Box Monthly

EYESCREAM Beauty Box Monthly

From $29.99 per box
Buy Now

EYESCREAM Beauty Bag is a monthly subscription box filled with new makeup items and skincare goodies that she can add to her growing beauty collection. This budget-friendly Sephora alternative includes 3-5 items that’ll add a little shimmer and shine to her makeup routine with a mix of products including eye shadows, brushes, and other beauty products.

Shipping: All boxes are shipped by the 15th of every month. Shipping times vary depending on location, but typically take between 2-5 business days. Order by the end of the month to receive current box. First box is shipped within a week of subscribing. If you have any questions, feel free to contact us! We usually respond within the same day!

Customer Review

“Beautiful products. Loved the queen eye shadow palette. And the eye shadow stick. In agua my favorite color. Awesome” - Robin M.

Essential Bi-Monthly Subscription

Essential Bi-Monthly Subscription

From $34.95 per box
Buy Now

With Love Goodly, not only will you be buying cruelty-free, full-size makeup, skincare, jewelry, and wellness items (valued up to $100), but you’ll also be donating to charity. Take care of yourself or a loved one, with lengthening mascara, freshening mists, healthy supplements, and more, while supporting everything from cervical cancer research to rescuing and rehoming research animals.

Shipping: We ship by the 5th every other month: Feb, Apr, Jun, Aug, Oct, Dec. Orders placed after the 5th will ship within 1-3 business days. To get the current bi-monthly box, you must order by/before the 15th (or until supplies last): Jan 15 for Dec/Jan, Mar 15 for Feb/Mar, May 15 for Apr/May, Jul 15 for Jun/Jul, Sept 15 for Aug/Sep, Nov 15 for Oct/Nov.

Customer Review

"I loved this box. Everything was cruelty free. Every item gives back to charities. And the products were FABULOUS. Unboxed on Arkansas Gals on youtube. Highly recommend" - Andrea K.

Mindful Box by Mindful Souls

Mindful Box by Mindful Souls

From $39.97 per box
Buy Now

Looking for a self-care box that will take them deeper into healing energy work? The Mindful Box by Mindful Souls helps them discover how everything from crystal work and aromatherapy, to affirmations and sacred jewelry can enhance their health and well-being. Simplifying spirituality and making it accessible for everyone, each monthly box will help them get acquainted to an array of spiritual tools and explore their innermost self.

Shipping: Free shipping to USA First Mindful Box will be shipped immediately and will be delivered within the next 2-5 days. All the following boxes will be sent on the 7th of each month!

Customer Review

“I'm in love with these boxes. I'm on my fourth month. April did NOT disappoint🥰. As always quality items. I get so excited each month to see my gifts. Best membership ever! Inspiring and beautiful. I highly recommend to give this a try. It wont disappoint.” - Shannon D.

Seen from above, a woman holds a box that says My Therabox. It contains a pink self care book and several scented items.

TheraBox - Self Care Box

From $37.99 per box
Buy Now

Shipping: ✨ Reserve your “WINTER” TheraBox today with up to $500+ worth of therapist-curated winter wellness rituals that make the perfect holiday gift for your partner, friends, family, colleagues and of course — you! ✨ Orders placed between November 25 - December 25 will ship within 2-5 business days starting December 1.

Paradise Delivered Premium Box

Paradise Delivered Premium Box

From $40.83 per box
Buy Now

If rest and relaxation are high on their wishlist, the Premium Box from Paradise Delivered has got them covered! Self-care in the way of hand-selected bath goodies, beauty products, accessories, treats, and a good read makes a thoughtful gift for every occasion and beyond. No spa trip required: they can simply open the box, draw a warm bath, and enjoy some quality "me time."

Shipping: Your box will ship on or before the 8th day of every month. New subscribers can order up until the 25th of the month to receive that month's box. Following boxes ship on the 8th of the month.

Customer Review

“WOW! Best customer service I’ve experienced in awhile. Been a subscriber for a year. Have loved all my boxes. For the first time last box was missing an item. Email to customer service was answered in 12 hours. Very gracious. Replacement product received in less than a week.” – Army S.

Hey Doll! holiday box promotion with silver, white, and navy ornaments. Ships in December while supplies last.

Hey Doll! Teen+Tween Subscription Box for Girls

From $42.50 per box
Buy Now

Let the self-care—and self-love—start flowing early for the teens and tweens in your life with Hey Doll!’s subscription box. Each package contains between three and five high-quality lifestyle items like nail polish, bath bombs, and fuzzy eye masks that provide motivation, direction, and support for girls as they navigate through a season of major personal change. There’s also an accompanying interactive website to help reinforce the #heydollstrong movement!

Shipping: First box ships within 4–5 business days of ordering. Subsequent boxes ship bi-monthly in Dec, Feb, Apr, Jun, Aug & Oct. 12-month subscribers receive boxes monthly. International orders may be subject to higher shipping costs.

Customer Review

"You can tell the items in my daughter's box were hand picked and carefully curated. Each piece matched the theme perfectly. The shipping was timely and the message was awesome. We both enjoyed the box and the uniqueness of the design." - Sonya J.

Browse other fun beauty subscription boxes here at Cratejoy!