Home /Box Insider/Your Subscription Box Match Based on Your Favorite Store

Your Subscription Box Match Based on Your Favorite Store

Updated December 10, 2025 by Meredith Raico

Whether it’s Whole Foods, Lush, or Michael’s, we all have our favorite stores we’re loyal to and frequent often. But what to do when you’re craving a change of pace to the usual?

That’s where a subscription box comes in!

With all the options on Cratejoy’s marketplace, you might be overwhelmed with trying to pick which box is right for you. Not to worry: We’ve done the heavy lifting for you and paired you with a box pick for 17 popular and loved stores – think Victoria’s Secret, Nordstrom, Starbucks, and more!

Sure, these subscription boxes might be lesser-known, but the curation, quality, and one-of-a-kind products found in each of these boxes are what make them special. Plus, you’ll get the bonus of discovering new brands and smaller companies you can feel good about supporting. Who knows, you might just find you enjoy your box pair equally (and maybe even more)!

Bath Bevy Subscription - Monthly

From $39.56 per box

Buy Now

Help them reduce stress and relax with a calming, luxurious bath experience from Bath Bevy. This thoughtfully curated subscription offers handmade bath and body products like bath bombs, soaps, scrubs, bath salts, bubble bath and more. Don’t have a tub? Bath Bevy now has a “tubless” option with shower steamers, lotions, body wash, whipped soaps and more.

Shipping: Subscribe now for the December Home for the Holidays box - begins shipping the first week of December via USPS. Following boxes ship the first week of the month.

Customer Review

"I have been subscribed to this box for 5 months and I love it every month! Everything smells amazing and none of the products bother my skin. I have eczema and can’t use most store bought scented products. I love the themes every month and everything is super cute!" - Lauren E.

Monthly Barbella Box

From $54.99 per box

Buy Now

CrossFit has become a lifestyle that makes physical fitness a priority. Commit to healthy living with Barbella Box, a fitness subscription that's packed with handpicked products from well-known suppliers and those that are new on the scene. From supplements and protein blends to apparel and workout gear, this curated box is made by women, for women, to bring an extra dose of motivation.

Shipping: If you purchase your first box BETWEEN 1st-16th of the month, you will receive your first box between the 22nd-30th or 31st. If you purchase AFTER the 16th, you will receive your first box the following month between the 22nd 30th or 31st.

Customer Review

“LOVE LOVE LOVE LOVE I can't even say it enough! It's like Christmas every 20th... I am always SO excited to see what's coming. I have never been disappointed in the almost 2 years that I have been a member!” – Kiersten Y.

Mondo Size

From $18.33 per box

Buy Now

Zine-o-Matic makes it easy to get good quality zines sent directly to their doorstep. With some of the best indie zines from cities across the U.S., you'll unpack a monthly box filled with a curated assortment of zines, plus some fun add-ins. Each zine will transport you to a new creative world with beautiful artistry, talented writing, and loads of original content. And, it makes a great gift for all your fellow creatives!

Shipping: We ship on the 1st of every month!

Customer Review

"This is my favorite thing I've received monthly for quite a time. So much support for many small artists and always introducing me to cool new creators!" - Andrea M.

Teens Skin and facial care Subscription Box

From $44.99 per box

Buy Now

Shipping: This is a quarterly subscription. Your first box will be shipped to you in 1-2 business days from placing your order and then every three months. Pay for 6 month or a year in advance and get discount on your subscription.

Quarterly Subscription Fiction Box of 4x New Surprise Books From A Box of Stories Book Club - Mystery Books Gift Box For Book Lovers

From $51.29 per box

Buy Now

Shipping: Boxes arrive every other month. Subscriptions automatically renew. Skip/Cancel anytime. "Your first box will ship within 2-6 business days after your order is placed & for united states customers box will be delivered within 3-4 weeks"

Snack Box for Students - College Snack Gift Box | Back to School Snack Basket & Candy Box (50+ Snacks)

From $32.00 per box

Buy Now

Shipping: Additional boxes (after your first shipment) will be sent between the 9th - 12th of each month. Snack boxes are shipped via USPS or UPS ground shipping. Delivery times vary depending on your location but generally take 3-7 business days to arrive. Shipping & delivery dates are NOT guaranteed.

Luxury VIP Gifts

From $99.99 per box

Buy Now

Shipping: Boxes ship out between the 25th and 26th of each month, depending on the sign-up date (sent out approximately 30 days after your first shipment). A tracking number is provided once the item ships via USPS. FedEx or UPS. FOR INTERNATIONAL ORDERS, THE RECIPIENT PAYS ANY ADDITIONAL TAXES AND/OR FEES. SALES FINAL.

New Mom & Baby product of the month - All natural and organic skincare and pampering subscription

From $14.40 per box

Buy Now

Shipping: This is a monthly subscription. Your first item will be shipped to you in 1-2 business days from placing your order and then every month. Pay for 3 month, 6 month or a year in advance and get discount on your subscription.