The Best Gifts for Horse Lovers & Equestrians Who Have Everything

Updated by Meredith Raico

We understand it can be hard to figure out the perfect gift for a horse lover if you aren’t an equestrian yourself. Not with Cratejoy! Check out our favorite horse lover subscription boxes that are perfect Christmas gifts, birthdays, or just to bring a smile to the face of your horseback riding cowgirl.

What do you buy someone who loves horses?

Shopping for a person in your life who loves horses isn’t easy. Where do you begin? With Cratejoy, your giftee can get a great gift every month. Because horse experts have compiled the perfect accessories, tools, and fun equestrian gifts like horse jewelry into monthly horse-themed gift boxes, you can close all of the Etsy and Amazon tabs you have open. Stick with us.

Seriously, don’t order them another gift card when you’ve got this great gift guide. If you choose any of the unique gift ideas below, the horse girl (or boy!) in your life is sure to thank you. They’re great for all ages and experience levels.

What are the best gifts for horse lovers?

We have the best gifts, from birthday gifts to the holidays, for horse lovers that are worth the sprint to the finish line. Gift-giving has never been easier than a subscription box that keeps on giving. So saddle up, then giddy up and get shopping!

Perfect Pawtrait Dog Club

Perfect Pawtrait Dog Club

From $26.99 per box
Buy Now

An ideal subscription for any pet lover, the PETure Perfect subscription is sure to be a hit delivering extra special home goods sporting their beloved pets. Using real photos of pets or portraits drawn by an experienced artist, each month’s box features items like mugs, coasters and other goodies all bearing a favorite furry face, plus a pet milestone card and a recipe card for a pet treat.

Shipping: We ship on the 4th day of each month. (We need a few days to create the illustration so please be aware that your first box may be a little later if you order close to the 4th of the month.)

Customer Review

“I could not be more pleased with my first box. After a covid related shipping goof and a quick resolution by Claire, Box #1 finally arrived. She nailed Murphy's expression and his details - right down to his collar! I'm so impressed and can't wait to see what's next.” – Joanne R.

The Adults & Crafts Crate

The Adults & Crafts Crate

From $33.00 per box
Buy Now

There’s no need to get bogged down in project planning when the pros behind the Adults & Crafts Crate have got it covered. Each monthly box sends at least 1 new Pinterest-worthy craft project, including all the supplies, tools, and illustrated step-by-steps to teach new crafting techniques while making one-of-a-kind keepsakes.

Shipping: New orders will ship within five business days! If you need a gift printout before we ship, just message us! Then, will ship around the 25th of each month. If you need a kit by a certain date (i.e. birthday), just message us after you order and we will get that set up for you! You can order now even if you want it to start in the future.

Customer Review

"I received the engraving kit and I love it! I practiced on an old glass weigh scale to get the hang of engraving. I then started the glass coasters using pictures off google. I am sooo happy with how they turned out! It’s very relaxing and is a great stress reliever. I have a few people now wanting me to make them sets of coasters :)" - Megan T.

Yarn Shop Mystery Box

Yarn Shop Mystery Box

From $32.91 per box
Buy Now

Shipping: We ship on the first Saturday of every month.

Monthly Barbella Box

Monthly Barbella Box

From $54.99 per box
Buy Now

CrossFit has become a lifestyle that makes physical fitness a priority. Commit to healthy living with Barbella Box, a fitness subscription that's packed with handpicked products from well-known suppliers and those that are new on the scene. From supplements and protein blends to apparel and workout gear, this curated box is made by women, for women, to bring an extra dose of motivation.

Shipping: If you purchase your first box BETWEEN 1st-16th of the month, you will receive your first box between the 22nd-30th or 31st. If you purchase AFTER the 16th, you will receive your first box the following month between the 22nd 30th or 31st.

Customer Review

“LOVE LOVE LOVE LOVE I can't even say it enough! It's like Christmas every 20th... I am always SO excited to see what's coming. I have never been disappointed in the almost 2 years that I have been a member!” – Kiersten Y.

Monthly Handmade Luxury Body Butter & Foaming Sugar Scrub Box

Monthly Handmade Luxury Body Butter & Foaming Sugar Scrub Box

From $26.16 per box
Buy Now

Shipping: Boxes will ship on the 11th of every month

Peace & Pages Monthly Subscription

Peace & Pages Monthly Subscription

From $24.75 per box
Buy Now

This peaceful book box includes a featured novel each month, as well as self-care items -- like bath & body products and aromatherapy -- exclusively from small independent businesses. Every individual reader receives a novel specially selected for them from a curated collection of genres.

Shipping: **Orders placed at this time will begin with the January box, shipping the first week of January. Will not arrive prior to Christmas.** Please note, the "as low as" price is the yearly prepay option cost. Check out the Q & A sections on our website for more info!

Customer Review

“This is the book box I look forward to every month! I get a book in the genres I enjoy and several full size relaxing products. I’m not a fan of the boxes with lots of trinkets I won’t use so Peace and Pages is perfect for me!” – Tanya B.

Mystery Gift Box | Wicked Good

Mystery Gift Box | Wicked Good

From $29.95 per box
Buy Now

Shipping: New Subscribers: your first box is shipped within 1-3 business days of ordering. Subsequent boxes ship the 10-15th of each month. ❤ Fast & Free Shipping to US destinations! We ship worldwide. #SmellWickedGood Thank you for your support. #SmellWickedGood

Box of Blessings

Box of Blessings

From $29.99 per box
Buy Now

Right from the first box, International Blessings subscribers are wowed by the quality of craftsmanship packed inside. But the beauty doesn't start and stop with the handcrafted jewelry, colorful textiles and intricate handmade goodies. This box is on a mission to help break the cycle of poverty by providing honorable work to talented artisans around the globe.

Shipping: Order by the last day of the month in order to receive the next months box. For example, if you order between March 1st-31st, your first box will ship in April. Orders placed on April 1st will ship in May. Boxes ship by the 6th of every month.

Customer Review

“Out of every single subscription box I have gotten over the years this one stands out among them all by not only being the absolute best freaking box I've gotten to date(and that is A LOT)and what makes it even more spectacular is the fact that subscribing for this one in particular actively and consistently works to help impoverished people throughout the entire world. Absolutely freaking brilliant! 10/10 do recommend.” – Ali T.

Box of Maine Subscription

Box of Maine Subscription

From $41.66 per box
Buy Now

While famous for fresh-caught lobster, the Box of Maine subscription shows off some of the other culinary delights that hail from this seaside state. Get name-brand products like Humpty Dumpty snacks, Moxie sodas, and Marshmallow Fluff. Enjoy tasting fresh blueberry jams, real deal maple syrup, whoopie pies, coffees, teas and plenty more. With 7-10 handpicked items, the box is packed to delight!

Shipping: Estimated transit time is 2-6 business days. Ships in a branded Box of Maine. Invoice will not be included in box.

Customer Review

"Love this box. Everything has been delicious. Good mix of items & good quality too. Definitely a winner!" - Connie M.

Didn’t the the perfect horse-theme gift? Check out the other gift guides below for more great ideas!