Valentine's Day Gifts for Your Crush Made to Delight (2024)

Updated by Timothy Paradis

With the day of love and all that mushy stuff just around the corner, now is the perfect opportunity to grab some subtle gifts for a crush and let them know they’ve captured your heart. Whether you've been hanging out in the friend zone or you’re yet to say 'I love you' and make it official, a romantic gift basket can help you seal the deal. More impressive than a simple Valentine's Day card or curated playlist, your secret crush will appreciate the caring gesture.

From plant and music lovers to foodies and coffee enthusiasts , the marketplace has curated monthly boxes that make awesome Valentine’s gifts for your crush. Play cupid for the day, and instead of sending love notes, send a curated gift box. And, soon enough, you'll be getting all the heart eyes. 😍

What are the best Valentine’s Day gifts for your crush?

Shaker & Spoon Cocktail Club

Shaker & Spoon Cocktail Club

From $49.91 per box
Buy Now

Mix things up by giving them a craft cocktail subscription box. Each month, subscribers will get three unique and tasty cocktail recipes, along with everything needed (minus the liquor) to whip up 12 delicious drinks. Every Shaker & Spoon box focuses on a specific liquor, so they’ll be able to make the most of their home bar. Whether they’re celebrating a special occasion, getting together with friends, or just building their bartender expertise, this monthly box will have subscribers raising a glass in delight.

Shipping: The Begin Again Box is slated to ship the week of August 5th. **IF YOU NEED A BOX SOONER, WRITE TO US by clicking the CONTACT SELLER button (bottom of the page) and we’ll hook you up with a different box from our vault!**

Customer Review

"Gave this as a gift and got to try some of the cocktails. The cachaca box was really fun! Really interesting combinations and usually some ingredients leftover for another batch of cocktails." - Leyna M.

Fudge and More Variety Box

Fudge and More Variety Box

From $48.00 per box
Buy Now

Take classic candies to the next level with a monthly box from Nellie’s Sweet Shoppe, one of many fun retro candy subscription boxes. Choose from 3 subscription options, delivering either 2 or 6 squares of fudge, or the variety box that includes 2 squares of fudge, caramels, saltwater taffy, and specialty truffles. Using time-tested family recipes, each box delivers new delicious flavors for the perfect indulgence.

Shipping: Free Shipping. Ships between the 15th-19th Ships from within the US.

Customer Review

"I’ve been getting this for my mum for over a year now, and she looks forward to it every month! Flavors are great and there always a fun new option!!" - Renee S.

SketchBox

SketchBox

From $20.00 per box
Buy Now

SketchBox is a monthly art supply subscription box that empowers artists of any age with unique, full-sized art supplies to create a surprise project. It’s the perfect way to spark creativity and keep the inspiration coming!

Shipping: We ship our boxes on the 25th of each month to arrive by the 1st.

Customer Review

“I purchased a gift subscription for my daughter a year ago and she has asked for it again for her birthday. Each box that we have received has given her the opportunity to try out a medium she has never used before and convert her into loving charcoal (Sketchbox introduced her to it) and using ink vs. pencil. .” -Stacy

Date Night Box Subscription

Date Night Box Subscription

From $23.33 per box
Buy Now

The creation of a team of marriage and family therapists, each monthly box is designed to strengthen any relationship, delivering a themed date that includes challenges and activities to give couples a night of intimate fun and laughs!

Shipping: Your first box will ship within 5 business days of the order being placed. Your subscription renews on the same day of the month as your first order based on your subscription type (month-to-month, three-month, or six-month). All renewing shipments (your second shipment and onward) will ship within 10 business days of the renewal date.

Customer Review

“We loved our date with Date Crate. It took a moment to get over the awkward feeling of trying something new but it ended up sparking lots of conversation and laughter we otherwise wouldn't have had. We're trying out our second date crate tomorrow!” – Surrey A.

Brothers Coffee - Single 12oz Bag

Brothers Coffee - Single 12oz Bag

From $19.00 per box
Buy Now

Support coffee with a cause by upgrading your morning Timmies' brew with a monthly subscription box from Brothers Coffee Company. This box focuses on single-origin, ethically sourced coffees, and tells the unique story of a different independent roaster and their mission on how to make the world a better place. Choose the single, double or triple for up to 3 bags of fresh coffee roasted to your personal specifications.

Shipping: Your package will ship within the first week of every month. We aim to get customers coffee within 1 week of roast. Please order by the end of the month to get the current box.

Customer Review

“I gave this as a Christmas gift to my boyfriend and he tells everyone about how amazing it is! Every time we have a cup of coffee, he repeats how amazing each cup is even though it’s from the same bag; it’s like a renewed enjoyment in every cup! After the 3-month subscription, we resubscribed—and I know I’ll be subscribing again after that.” – Lindsay R.

1 BAG

1 BAG

From $11.38 per box
Buy Now

A best-seller for good reason, with LOLJerky they'll join a pack of satisfied jerky lovers enjoying some of the tastiest dried meat on the market. Bringing between 1-6 bags of low-sugar, low-preservative artisanal beef jerky, each box sends a variety of classic and new flavors, like aloha teriyaki, sriracha bacon, and sweet citrus. Committed to showcasing and supporting small producers, it's the perfect gift.

Shipping: Orders ship by the 15th of each month directly to your door!

Customer Review

“My husband gets so excited when the package arrives. It’s the Christmas gift that keeps on giving lol.” - Kathleen G.

4 Sheet Masks

4 Sheet Masks

From $10.24 per box
Buy Now

FaceMaskTonight is an affordable and fun way to enjoy spa-quality masks and facial treatments right at home. Available in 3 subscription options, choose to have 4, 8, or 12 hand-picked masks delivered per month. Whether you’re snuggling up with your favorite rerun or whipping up dinner, pampering and hydrating your skin is as easy as 1, 2, 3!

Shipping: We ship every Monday! We are working to best serve you with more reliable and affordable/free shipping. Thank you for your support.

Customer Review

“Such an incredible variety and opportunity to try delightful sheet masks! No two masks were alike and I loved the thought!” – Bobbi I.

The Paper Lover

The Paper Lover

From $20.16 per box
Buy Now

Box reviews say that it's so much fun to get cute, seasonal and personalized stationery every month from Pretty Paper Club. This monthly subscription brings high-end stationery featuring fun designs that are customized with the name of your choosing, along with coordinated accessories, like gel pens, labels and one-of-a-kind office supplies.

Shipping: A tracking number will be emailed as soon as your custom notecards are prepared to ship.

Customer Review

"I've purchased several kits as gifts for my sister, bff, Mother-in-law, myself, and also my son's teacher. Everyone was very happy with the boxes. Super cute stationary, some of my favorite pens and adorable little extras. I even got some personalized post cards for my kiddo to send mail to his grandparents and cousins." - Reagan H.

Finders Seekers Mysteries

Finders Seekers Mysteries

From $26.40 per box
Buy Now

Solve puzzles while traveling the world with this thrilling escape room game! Finders Seekers is the perfect gift for puzzle solvers and mystery fans who loves a challenge! Enjoy this game with the family or venture off and uncover complex clues with a single use mystery game inclusive of hands-on and online gameplay.

Shipping: We ship on the 23rd of each month, for all orders placed by the 21st. All subsequent games will ship by the 23rd of each month. For last-minute gifts, we provide a fun PDF gift message that you can personalize and email or print. Shipping is $6 within the US, Canada shipping: $7.95.

Customer Review

“I have been getting Finders Seekers boxes for over a year, and I cannot lie, I'm obsessed. The mysteries are a lot of fun, and they are so much fun to do with friends, especially those that haven't done something like this before. Occasionally, the puzzles are evil (I'm looking at you, Paris box!), but the fact that after a year they can still challenge me is a good thing.” - Rachel C.

Succulents Box

Succulents Box

From $4.95 per box
Buy Now

Succulents are a great addition to any room. Start or add to a existing collection with the Succulents Box, a subscription that sends a variety of different succulents in 2-inch pots. Choose to get between 1 to 4 plants each month, and whether they're a first-timer or have a time-tested green thumb, each month's box is sure to bring something new.

Shipping: Your first box ships 3 business days after purchase. Your next box will ship between the 18th-20th each month. Your plant will be meticulously wrapped in bubble wrap and tissue papers and shipped in a sturdy box. Most 2" plants are shipped in their original plastic pot with soil. *** All of our packages are sterilized before leaving the door.

Customer Review

“Beautiful plant. Perfect packaging. Quick shipment and even comes with care instructions!!!” – Faith B.

Bubbles & Books

Bubbles & Books

From $26.91 per box
Buy Now

Romance readers, rejoice! Bubbles & Books sends a slew of romance novels to subscribers each month, with 1-2 paperbacks, 5+ bonus romance ebooks, and an assortment of premium bath and spa products for a truly relaxing evening. Each month is a welcome surprise, delivering luxe items such as sheet masks, bath salts and bombs, handmade and whipped soaps, candles, teas, and (of course) bubble bath.

Shipping: Boxes ship between the 18th and 21st of every month.

Customer Review

"Great subscription for reading and relaxing! Perfect for those who love to soak!" - Juliana J.

Didn't see the perfect Valentine's Day gift for the person you're crushing on? Check out the Gift Shop !