Horror & Mystery Boxes | Halloween Book Boxes & Games | Cratejoy
Choose Your Thrill: Horror Books, Mystery Games & More
Puzzle Monthly - Monthly Subscription
by Puzzle Monthly
Welcome to Puzzle Monthly! We are a Monthly Puzzle Subscription Box delivering a fun, exciting and challenging puzzle to your door every month!
From $32.92 / box
Ships fast
Free shipping
Puzzles for Pros - Puzzle Monthly Subscription
by Puzzle Monthly
Welcome to Puzzle Monthly! We are a Monthly Puzzle Subscription Box delivering a fun, exciting and challenging puzzle to your door every month!
From $37.99 / box
Free shipping
20% off
Puzzling Newspaper Subscription - The Hincks Gazette
by Bluefish Games
Solve puzzles and explore the perplexing town of Hincksville. Perfect for board gamers, escape room players, and the curious-minded.
From $23.00 / box
Ships fast
Free shipping
1st box
50% off
Quarterly Subscription Fiction Box of 4x New Surprise Books From A Box of Stories Book Club - Mystery Books Gift Box For Book Lovers
by A Box of Stories Surprise Book Club
Searching for your next best page-turner? Dive into a box of stories 4 x Surprise book box.
From $51.29 / box
Free shipping
1st box
10% off
Saltwater Taffy Box
by The Candy Stop
The Candy Stop Saltwater Taffy Box is filled with delicious saltwater taffy in a variety of flavors.
From $11.70 / box
1st box
50% off
Preferred Seller
Scarlet Envelope: Secret Society - Escape Room at Home - Subscriptionby Scarlet Envelope
Solve a series of immersive mysteries all set in different times and worlds!
From $21.50 / box
Free shipping
10% off
Silverquicken Quest Club Membership
by Silverquicken Education, Inc.
Give the gift of puzzles, games, and mysteries for your pre-teen to solve individually or with friends!
From $25.99 / box
Free shipping
Preferred Seller
Sin Cityby A Killing Affair
Become the Detective in this Riveting Murder Mystery Game!
From $26.67 / box
1st box
25% off
Spooky Halloween Gift Box for Kids – Candy, Snacks & Surprise Treats - Monthly Holiday Snack Box
by SentWithCareUSA
Celebrate every holiday with a monthly snack box! Each month brings festive candy, snacks, and surprises themed to the season — from spooky Halloween treats to cozy Christmas goodies.
From $36.00 / box
Ships fast
Free shipping
1st box
50% off
Surprise Monthly Box Of 4 New Mixed Books - Mystery Subscription Gift Box For Book Lovers
by A Box of Stories Surprise Book Club
Searching for your next best page-turner? Dive into a box of stories 4x surprise mystery book box
From $51.29 / box
Free shipping
10% off
Tales from Lanternlight Hollow
by Tales from Lanternlight Hollow
A letter every month with a cozy mystery, a craft, and two recipes
From $18.33 / box
The Amazing Mystery Box 1
by The Amazing Mystery Box
A variety of subscription or buy now boxes filled with toys, tees & collectables sent from the UK
From $30.95 / box
Free shipping
1st box
50% off
Preferred Seller
The Conundrum Box - Escape Room Game in a Boxby The Conundrum Box
Escape boredom! A monthly adventure box, part escape room, part choose-your-own adventure!
From $27.80 / box
Ships fast
Low Stock
Puzzle Post Mystery
by UnboxBoardom
Solve the mystery of what happened to Lucy with this puzzle-filled letter containing clues pieced together from her Europe trip. Unravel a tale of lies and corruption through 7 challenges.
$15.00
Free shipping
Rick and Morty Amazing Mystery Box
by The Amazing Mystery Box
Rick & Morty Mystery Box: New 6-item assortment with plush surprise. First 24 orders guaranteed full set. Get interdimensional merch before it sells out!
$33.76
15% off
Stephen Sondheim Sweeney Todd inspired Embroidered Apron
by Broadway Boxed Up
Embroidered apron with adjustable strap featuring Mrs. Lovett's Meat Pies design from Sweeney Todd. Perfect for cooking/baking. Shipped with Broadway Boxed Up subscription.
$30.00
Free shipping
Surprise Me! Mystery Gift Bundle
by One Girl Inspired
Mystery bundle with 3-4 surprise products like self-care/beauty items, novelties, books/journals & jewelry! Enjoy the thrill of discovering what's inside. Free shipping!
$25.00
Free shipping
The Amazing Mystery Taster Gift Box 1
by The Amazing Mystery Box
Mystery box with t-shirt & cool TV/movie merch for adult & teen collectors. Select size or 'don't know' for an unsized version perfect for gifting. XXXL now available!
$33.76
The Amazing Mystery Taster Gift Box 2
by The Amazing Mystery Box
Mystery gift box containing exclusive themed merchandise for adult/teen fans. Choose t-shirt size or 'don't know' for alternative items. Perfect for collectors & pop culture enthusiasts.
$33.76
1st box
30% off
Rocky Horror Picture Show inspired Enamel Pin
by Broadway Boxed Up
Rock your love for Rocky Horror with this glitzy enamel pin! Featuring sparkling white teeth, a black rubber pin back offers cozy wear. Officially licensed merch for fans.
$12.00
Sold out
