Classic Candy Box

by Classic Candy Box
A monthly subscription box filled with a variety of hard-to-find classic American candy.
21 reviews

Plans as low as

$21.89/ month

Buying Options

Classic Candy Box reviewsReviews

Write a Review

See below...

Feb 24, 2021
Stephanie P.
1 Review
2 Helpful Votes
Subscribed for 17 days

After I messaged this company expressing concern about the whereabouts of a gift I purchased on 12/27/20 and hadn’t heard anything until yesterday 2/23/20 (after writing a negative review), they responded saying that the box was actually delivered last month. In checking with my family, this was true!
My issue is that the company was unresponsive when I first messaged them the first week of Feb and only responded once I left a negative review. My other issue is with Cratejoy because it still says on their website “your package will arrive soon!” When you’re sending a gift to someone you don’t really want to reach out and be like... hey, did you ever get that thing I sent? Awkward. They should fix that.
In my review yesterday I gave them 0 stars but upped it to 3/5 because the package arrived and the company did eventually respond to me.

Verified Purchase


Aug 15, 2020
Rachel B.
2 Reviews
6 Helpful Votes
Subscribed for 1 month

I ordered this box as a gift for 83 year old grandma. Based on the descriptions and pictures, I thought the boxes would be classic , hard to find candy, that she would remember from her childhood.
Instead she says her box had nerds and straburst and taffy .
I'm super disappointed.

Verified Purchase