EDITORS' PICKS 2021

Comma Vintage: Quarterly

by Comma Vintage
The Vintage Menswear Subscription Service
43 reviews

Product Details

Vintage Menswear Curated for You.

Comma delivers curated boxes of vintage menswear. We specialize in quality American-made clothing from legendary brands, including Levi's, Pendleton, L. L. Bean, Nike, Champion, and more, as well as forgotten makers from decades past. Please see our FAQ before subscribing.

  • 1-3 pieces of authentic vintage clothing
  • Personal note included
  • A 1 year subscription = 4 shipments
  • Keep what you get! No styling fee.

Customer Questions (9)

3

Q: Will I get to personalize what I what and don’t want?Asked by Gabriel B., May 2019

Hi Gabriel,
Thanks for the question! After purchase, you will be emailed a comprehensive preferences survey in which you can detail your size, style preferences, and more.
If you love vintage t-shirts, you'll be able to tell us and we'll be sure to send some. If, for example, you're allergic to wool or you live in too hot a place to ever wear a sweater, you can tell us and we wont send you any.
I hope this answers your question!...

by Michael P., May 2019

1

Q: I’m 6’3”, 170 lbs, so finding vintage clothes that are long enough without being way too wide is really tough. How does this service do in matching the clothes in the boxes to the size needs of the customers?Asked by Adam Z., May 2019

Hi Adam,
We match customers via a comprehensive style survey delivered by email after subscription.
You're right that finding vintage clothing in tall sizes can be difficult. But because we acquire vintage clothing at scale and maintain a warehouse of vintage inventory, we're never had a subscriber we couldn't service. Dozens of our subscribers are 6'3" or taller.

by Michael P., May 2019

1

Q: I've seen several questions about outfitting taller men... and responses to the affirmative. However, at 6'8" / 250 lbs, I tend to be a bit more of a challenge. Do you think you could accommodate me?Asked by Michael P., July 2021

Comma Vintage answered...July 2021

Hi Michael,
Thanks so much for reaching out! We can absolutely accommodate you. While I'll acknowledge that certain items--say a t-shirt from a particular event or style of jacket from a specific brand--might not exist in all sizes, I'm confident that we can put together a box that fits your body and lifestyle.


1

Q: How is your size inclusivity? Many menswear sub boxes don't carry my size: 27" trouser, xs shirt, 7 shoe. Do you accommodate smaller gentlemen?Asked by Ivory K., March 2021

No answers yet! Be the first to help by adding an answer below.

Reviews (43)

I'm a woman, and everything fits!

Dec 18, 2019
Verified Purchase
Raman G.
1 Review
4 Helpful
Subscribed for 3 months

I'm a 5"10 130 lb 20 year old girl. They sent me 4 shirts in excellent condition, one even had the original tag on it. I didn't really know what kind of clothes I wanted just a general 40's to 70's era vibe and I got wide variety of shirts. I told them I usually fit an extra small men's size and everything I got fits insanely well. The package came with a page detailing every item and the last one being "Polo Shirt: We don't usually ship 4 items, but shoot, we've had this piece for a bit waiting for the right customer and I think you're it", it's my favourite item and its absolutely adorable.

Woah!!

Jun 22, 2018
Verified Purchase
Stanley S.
1 Review
3 Helpful
Subscribed for 9 months

Wow, I totally didn't know what to expect at first, but, WOW! Thank you so much! This is my first subscription and I was afraid if it'll be too hard to find something suitable for me as I can get kinda nit-picky about certain looks. I was even afraid if I was elaborating too much in my customer survey, but they really read through everything and paid extra close attention to what would work for me and what wouldn't. I received three items: a blue button-up, a hoodie and a wool tie. The blue button-up was exactly my style! In fact, I love it so much that I immediately wrote an email to Mike, the owner of Comma Vintage, to thank him personally before writing this review. I don't think I'll ever find something like this where I'm from. The design is simple, stripes, but it definitely stands out from my other striped clothes. It fits nicely as well and the material feels simply amazing! It's so light, perfect for my country's climate. I love how they wrote a personalized note to you, explaining the items in the box and why they chose them. It really shows how much attention to detail was spent on selecting the pieces. I just received my first box and I already can't wait for the next one, I always enjoy surprises and I was definitely surprised. Thank you, Comma Vintage!

Blown Away

Dec 04, 2018
Verified Purchase
Nicholas P.
1 Review
3 Helpful
Subscribed for 3 years

I had heard about Comma Vintage and saw some of their boxes online, but wasn’t sure what to really expect. When I signed up, Mike emailed me a questionnaire that was pretty in depth. It asked about my sizes, sure, but it went further by asking about my style, taste in music, favorite locations, and other fun questions that made it feel like a truly customized experience. Within two weeks, I got an email letting me know my first box was on the way and a couple days later it arrived. When I opened the box, there was a nice letter explaining what was inside, why it was selected, and some of the history and provenance of the items. I received a poli shirt from the late 80s that is most likely an official Nasa issue commemorative of a shuttle launch, an old crew neck sweatshirt that says Boston Beach Club (I live in Boston), and a brand new made in the USA t shirt with unbelievable graphics. In addition, I got an unopened pack of baseball cards from the 80s. Seeing the moustaches people wore back then was incredible, and it even included a young Roger Clemens. To top it off, I mentioned in my survey that Italy was one of my favorite locations, and the box included two old post cards from the 70s that spoke about how beautiful Rome and Florence was. Honestly, my mind was blown. I can’t wait for the next Comma Vintage box. One...

Amazing!

Apr 30, 2019
Verified Purchase
Aida C.
1 Review
2 Helpful
Subscribed for 3 months

This was such a good experience! I'm a size S/M woman, and the box I received included a fur-lined vintage leather bomber jacket, and an amazing 'angry rainbow badger' shirt - both of which fit perfectly. Included was a note explaining the provenance of each item, and how it related to the questionnaire/preference survey I submitted and it was so spot on! Brilliant!

Great gift for a vintage lover!

Aug 14, 2019
Verified Purchase
James W.
1 Review
1 Helpful
Subscribed for 2 months

Bought a box for my boss as a gift, and he loved it! His Comma Vintage shipment included an awesome L.L. Bean sweater, a corduroy shirt jacket, and a vintage tee. He thought it was a super cool and really unique gift. Thanks, Comma Vintage, for helping me on my quest to be the most beloved guy on the team.

Awesome

Jun 11, 2021
Verified Purchase
C S.
1 Review
1 Helpful
Subscribed for 2 months

Loved it, would definitely recommend!

Awesome surprise

Jun 19, 2019
Verified Purchase
Mark L.
1 Review
1 Helpful
Subscribed for 2 years

Have told all my friends, really enjoyed the first box.

Subscribe now!

Aug 28, 2019
Verified Purchase
Maxim N.
1 Review
1 Helpful
Subscribed for 3 years

Comma Vintage is a fantastic service. Michael is extremely communicative with shipments and the quality of the clothing is always high. They are also very willing to put in work to find the perfect piece for you. Can’t recommend them highly enough

RELIABLE AND AUTHENTIC

Nov 29, 2018
Verified Purchase
Elijah H.
1 Review
1 Helpful
Subscribed for 3 years

I wear every Comma Vintage Shirt that comes in the mail, my favorite is the UCONN Mens 1999 championship shirt. Everything is so well thought out and I love learning more about the clothes I get. So good!

A great Birthday gift

Jun 12, 2019
Verified Purchase
Veronica M.
1 Review
1 Helpful
Subscribed for 11 months

Very neat idea my boyfriend didn't really know how to react at first and doesn't believe there are 3 more boxes coming for him so it will be a great surprise thank you so much


Take $10 off your order with code "TAKEPAUSE"
Buy NowGive as a Gift
Shipping Policy
We ship 2 to 4 weeks after the subscription is paid. This gives us time to find the perfect item, as we may not yet have it in...
Cancellation & Refund Policy

Comma Vintage was featured in these articles…


Comma Vintage appears in these collections...


Questions for Comma Vintage?