Home /Box Insider/Geeky Gifts for Nerds, Gamers, and Cosplayers

Geeky Gifts for Nerds, Gamers, and Cosplayers

Updated April 25, 2024 by Shannon Ratliff

More than anything, a thoughtful gift says, “I like you just the way you are.” Gifts that celebrate our unique qualities and quirks, are impactful because they recognize what makes us who we are. Geeks, nerds, gamers, and enthusiastic fans all share one thing in common: zest and excitement for life. Tap into that joy and celebrate the lovable nerd in your life with a gift just as unique as they are.

Geek & Nerd Gift Ideas

From anime to Marvel comic books to Star Wars, Doctor Who, or Stranger Things, the Cratejoy market has brilliant, beloved corners of popular fandoms today for all of your gift occasions. Monthly subscription boxes are the gift that keep giving, and all nerd fans appreciate fresh stock of their beloved hobby.

Nerd subscription boxes speak to the fandom at hand. Boxes full of limited edition items, wearable gadgets, cool manga merch , and even prop replicas from sci-fi tv shows are all great geek fuel. From pop culture to video games, we’ve put together a fun gift guide of subscription boxes that fit your favorite nerd.

For the Pokemon Trainer

Catch them all with a Pokemon subscription box filled with rare and mystery trading cards! A monthly subscription is a great addition to their collection.

For Dungeon Master

RPG players will be delighted with all the dice, minis, and gameplay available on a monthly basis! Whether they are a veteran player or a newbie, these DnD subscriptions are perfect for nerdy game nights.

For the Disney Enthusiast

Get magic in every monthly box with a Disney subscription from Cratejoy! From snacks to pins, there's boxes for every Disney fanatic.

Whatever they nerd out to, Cratejoy has the perfect gift for them.

Pokemon Booster Pack Bundle (1995-2022)

From $18.66 per box

Buy Now

Shipping: New orders will ship in 3-7 business days. The following boxes will ship on the 1st of the next month.

Fangirl Monthly Box

From $19.00 per box

Buy Now

Stock up on the cutest Ghibli and Sailor Moon collectibles that you can wear and use as an accessory on your keychain. Fangirl Monthly delivers anime and manga-inspired accessories that you can't find anywhere else. With a different theme each month, get fandom-inspired designs like a Totoro jewelry case to match with a pair of Spirited Away dangly earrings.

Shipping: We ship between the 5th-10th of each month, so you will receive the box within the given month (and not after!).

"I absolutely loved my first box! It had a few different anime & manga products. I wear the items from this box almost every day. I highly suggest this subscription box for any anime & manga fans! :)" - Bailey D.

Mystery Toy Box

From $31.99 per box

Buy Now

Monthly Mystery Toy Box is a great gift lets anyone be a kid again. Each box contains 5-8 new premium toys worth over $65 from some of the top names – Funko, Medicom Toy, and Kidrobot. Boxes will never include the same toy twice, so every month is a total surprise! The subscription also includes discounts at the Mindzai online toy store to fulfill all his quirky toy desires!

Shipping: Your box will ship on the 15th of every month. Please order by the 1st of each month to ensure you get the current box. If you ordered from the 16th-31st, then your box will ship on the 15th of the next month. For existing subscribers, we ship on the 15th of every month and renew on the 1st Cancellations must be made before the 1st of the month

"Nothing but good things to say so far. The diversity has been on point and it seems like there is thought and effort put into the mystery toy box. I gave this as a gift to my girlfriend and she loves it. Thanks " - Vince M.

Cryptid Crate Monthy Subscription Box - Cratejoy Edition

From $43.00 per box

Buy Now

Happy subscribers attest that the team at Cryptid Crate goes above and beyond, curating delightful collections of all things cryptozoological. A great gift idea for any teen who's into the not-yet-substantiated species of the world, each monthly box delivers 4 to 7 handpicked curiosities, including graphic T-shirts, offbeat decor items, intriguing accessories, and books and films from some of the best independent producers and artisans in the game.

Shipping: - Cryptid Crate ships on the first weekday of every month (will ship a day or two earlier or later if first weekday is a holiday) - Every box will ordered within a calendar month will be included in the shipment that goes out on the 1st.

“Amazing! I was so excited to get this box and it did not disappoint! LOVE the t-shirt and one of my new favorite stickers came in this box. Can't wait for next month!!!” – Megan S.

Gaming Guru (Monthly)

From $29.99 per box

Buy Now

One of the best gifts for those who are addicted to board games is UnboxBoardom. Each box contains new games for every interest and experience level. Every month, the box includes something for the gaming guru. Every other month will include a new game for the causal gamer, and every three months the box includes a new game for beginners.

Shipping: Your box will ship around the 15th of your scheduled month. Please order by the end of the previous month to get the current box. NOTE: Gift notification messages will be sent at time of purchase unless specified otherwise in gift message box at checkout.

"Loved getting games each month this winter! It gave my husband and I something to look forward to and it was fun trying out new games we wouldn’t typically pick out!! Great customer service as well!" - Christine S.

Dungeon Crate™

From $28.65 per box

Buy Now

Dungeon Crate is a monthly subscription box that's going to take their tabletop setup to the next level. One of the best subscription boxes for Dungeon Masters and D&D guilds, this box is curated by in-the-know, experienced gamers who handpick and deliver a whole lotta loot, including RPG accessories, miniatures, and dice, plus downloadable adventures, campaigns, and maps.

Shipping: Cut offs for the current month are the 4th of the month. Boxes are shipped the third week of the month. Each crate includes a monthly code for exclusive digital downloads. Calculated shipping costs apply. Cancelling only stops the auto renewal process, this is a NON-REFUNDABLE item.

"Gave a 3mos sub to my 17yo son for his birthday and he LOVES it. He's into D&D, MTG, Yugioh and Pathfinder. He's asked for another 3mos for Christmas." - Leslie M.

The Heroes Tower Geeky Mystery Box

From $25.00 per box

Buy Now

Shipping: We believe the sooner you receive your mystery boxes the better. This way, if any problems or issues arise, we can handle the issue swiftly and efficiently.