Magickal Gifts That Witches Will Actually Use

Updated by Timothy Paradis

Gone are the days of hocus-pocus clichés like broomsticks and pointy hats. Modern witches have evolved into a vibrant, diverse community of free spirits, each with their own practices and tools. That can make it tricky to shop for them — but not to worry. Cratejoy offers a curated range of magickal gifts that are practical, purposeful, and always appreciated.

What Are the Best Witch Gifts?

The Witches Moon®

The Witches Moon®

From $48.00 per box
Buy Now

Featuring handcrafted, exclusive items to help any aspiring witch or pagan to deepen their craft and branch out into new directions, every witchcraft subscription box from The Witches Moon packs in an incredible value sending 10-20 unique items. Gift some spiritual practice goodies like hand-rolled spell candles, oracle and tarot cards, herbs, body care, spells and grimoire artwork for their very own book of shadows.

Shipping: If subscribing in November, your first box will ship between December 1st and 10th. As soon as your label is printed, you will receive an email with tracking information included. Most packages are shipped via USPS. Renewals are processed on the 15th of each month following the initial purchase of the subscription.

Customer Review

"Wow! Fantastic! Definitely worth the price paid! I received some really nice items beautifully curated around a theme. Everything in the box made sense and the quality of each item was way above my expectations! The box smelled soooo good when I opened it and every item felt like a treasure! Very happy with this purchase!” - April V.

The Witches Roots™ by The Witches Moon®

The Witches Roots™ by The Witches Moon®

From $27.00 per box
Buy Now

The Natural Craft is expertly and thoughtfully curated in this subscription box that focuses on the Magick flowing in their life. Altar items like dried herbs, magickal flowers, and spell coins add depth to their daily practice each month.

Shipping: If subscribing in November, your first box will ship between December 1st and 10th. As soon as your label is printed, you will receive an email with tracking information included. Renewals are processed on the 11th of each month following the initial purchase of the subscription. Shipping Cost: $6.00 (Subject to change)

Customer Review

“Received my first witch’s roots box. I got the lunar box. It’s great. Came with a little of this and a little of that. They have inspired me to start my book of shadows and start collecting all the little beautiful things I buy/find along my journey. Beautiful and put together very well for someone experienced or a newb. Thanks for the awesome start to a beautiful beginning.” - Kelly C.

The Initiate

The Initiate

From $27.24 per box
Buy Now

Tune into the natural rhythms of the universe with a monthly subscription from the Box of Shadows. The Initiate is designed for those who are new to seeking spiritual guidance, delivering introductory books, spells and basic rituals, along with essential supplies, altar decor, energetic crystals and jewelry. It's a great opportunity to start on the path towards self discovery, and learn sage wisdom from those with experience.

Shipping: To get the current month's box, orders must be placed by the 4th of that month. All boxes are shipped by the 10th.

Customer Review

"This subscription, Box of Shadows: The Initiate, was purchased for my wife. She absolutely loves it. She gets very excited for each package because it comes with something that supplements her current connection and/or gives her more to learn about. She will be continuing this subscription and referring it to others" - Jason C.

Magickal Earth - Basic Crystal Only New

Magickal Earth - Basic Crystal Only New

From $13.41 per box
Buy Now

With crystals, astrology and tarot, each box from Magickal Earth is curated to match the energy of the coming month. Help them get in touch with their own unique brand of spirituality with 4 subscription levels that bring an assortment of New Age provisions like reinvigorating crystals, astrological overviews, practical magic, and a tarot card drawn just for them.

Shipping: We ship on or around the 10th of every month, Our goal is that you receive the box by the 20th - 23rd of every month. As we follow the Astrological calendar. Note: International orders can not be guaranteed arrival at this time.

Customer Review

“I absolutely LOVE this box. It is my fav thing to receive every month, I am always impressed by it and I have used and loved every crystal I have been gifted. Thank you so much!” - Reba G.

An Herbal Apprentice subscription box sitting on a table, filled with loose leaf tea packets. A person is filling packets.

Herbal Apprentice Box

From $41.66 per box
Buy Now

Ideal for any person who loves learning something new and having a little DIY fun, the Herbal Apprentice Box is a subscription that's just waiting to expose them to the wide and wonderful world of home apothecary. Eco-friendly and holistic, each box brings DIY medicine-making projects complete with study guides, easy-to-follow recipes, seeds to start a personal medicinal garden, essential oils for aromatherapy, and more.

Shipping: If you select the Herbal Starter Kit as your first box, it will ship immediately. If you choose to wait for the next box, it will ship on the 15th of the month. Herbal Starter Kit Only: If you select a month-to-month subscription, your account will renew 14 days after your Herbal Starter Kit ships, to reserve next month's box for you.

Customer Review

“The Happy Heart box was my first monthly box from Apothecary at Home, and I'm so impressed! The artwork is beautiful, the treats delicious, and the herbs smell heavenly. I look forward to seeing how my herbal garden grows with the seeds provided each month. I highly recommend this monthly box to anyone on their path of healing with plants.”- Nicole O.

The Wheel of the Year Ritual Box

The Wheel of the Year Ritual Box

From $33.33 per box
Buy Now

Shipping: All boxes will be shipped Priority Mail approximately 6 days before the Sabbat. Yule Sabbat Boxes begin shipping December 15th.

Crystal of the Month

Crystal of the Month

From $14.00 per box
Buy Now

Delve into a world of well-being with Enchanted Crystal, sending curated crystals and minerals from across the globe. Choose from the Crystal of the Month plan, delivering a single stone, or the Crystal Variety Box which includes a mix of 4 to 6 crystals and a handcrafted cloth grid. Hand-selected with intention and packaged in eco-friendly materials, both subscription options include a bonus assortment of mini crystals and minerals.

Shipping: New subscriber's first box ships within 2 - 3 business days. Our crystals and minerals are natural, as the earth created them. We may use polished or shaped natural crystals to add to your enchantment. Boxes are custom-made every month, and not all subscribers will receive the same selections. ❤️

Customer Review

“My daughter LOVES this subscription box. I had to stop deliveries for a couple of months around Xmas and she was SO UPSET. Great Quality and Info... Thank you. Keep up the good work!!! We appreciate you....” – Angela J.

Sacred Space Crate

Sacred Space Crate

From $50.00 per box
Buy Now

Shipping: Boxes will be shipped before the 10th of every month. Orders placed during the Month will receive their 1st box the following Month. .

Monthly Witchy Box

Monthly Witchy Box

From $32.00 per box
Buy Now

Shipping: We ship on the 15th of each month unless it's your first order, then within three days.

The Witches Bounty by The Witches Moon™

The Witches Bounty by The Witches Moon™

From $77.00 per box
Buy Now

A great gift is The Witches Bounty by The Witches Moon, a monthly subscription that's packed with quality tools to help her explore spirituality. Each beautifully curated monthly box delivers a coordinating pendant, crystal and anointing oil based on unique energies throughout the year. Known for its energy vortexes and metaphysical communities, each exquisite one-of-a-kind pendant has been charged in Sedona, Arizona.

Shipping: If subscribing in November, your first box will ship between December 1st and 10th. As soon as your label is printed, you will receive an email with tracking information included. Renewals are processed on the 15th of each month following the initial purchase of the subscription.

Customer Review

"An absolutely beautiful box which includes a stunning high quality jewelry pendant, a beautiful art page about the featured item, natural scented custom incense, custom made oil, and rolled beeswax candle. My attached image has my last 4 months( I accidentally left out the art for Isis jewelry photo, but it's also stunning featuring yellows and blues)" - Allison T.

The Supreme

The Supreme

From $42.49 per box
Buy Now

Shipping: To get the current month's box, orders must be placed by the 4th of that month. All boxes are shipped by the 10th.

The Apothecary Crate

The Apothecary Crate

From $54.00 per box
Buy Now

Shipping: Each curated Apothecary Crate is available for two months and clients will have their Crates shipped on the first day of the season’s first month. Once subscribed, you will receive our Crate Reveals - an email preview of our next Crate. If you subscribe in the middle of the season, your first box will ship will ship 2-weeks after your order.

The Priestess

The Priestess

From $33.99 per box
Buy Now

The Priestess Box of Shadows is a "Wicca-inspired" box that offers curated collections for dabblers, explorers, Wiccans, pagans, and advanced seekers alike. Personalize their practice for each sabbat with valuable resources and expert guidance, including worship supplies, adornments, altar decor, and pagan-related gift items.

Shipping: To get the current month's box, orders must be placed by the 4th of that month. All boxes are shipped by the 10th.

Customer Review

“It was a magical little box .... Everything was well presented and excellent quality.. All I was looking for and more!” - Nicole R.

Past Box: Romance and Ritual

Past Box: Romance and Ritual

From $49.99 per box
Buy Now

Shipping: If you select the Herbal Starter Kit as your first box, it will ship immediately. If you choose to wait for the next box, it will ship on the 15th of the month. Herbal Starter Kit Only: If you select a month-to-month subscription, your account will renew 14 days after your Herbal Starter Kit ships, to reserve next month's box for you.

Beautiful Witchy Gifts Made With Purpose

If you’re not sure where to start, you can’t go wrong with The Witches Moon®. Known for its altar-ready tools and detailed curation, it’s a premium gift that inspires ritual practice month after month. For a more herbal-focused option, The Witches Roots™ delivers botanicals, teas, and ritual supplies that make everyday magic more accessible.

Looking for something flexible? The Initiate is designed as a starter box with accessible tools and guidance, making it a thoughtful choice for beginners or anyone refining their craft.

For Spiritual Alignment

Encourage connection with spirit and self with Crystal of the Month, a subscription that introduces a new specimen each cycle, complete with notes for use and intention. For a deeper journey, Wheel of the Year Witch Box celebrates seasonal sabbats with rituals and tools that honor the turning of the year.

Other unique paths include The Supreme and The Priestess, both of which offer curated tools, rituals, and inspiration for witches exploring specific archetypes or traditions.

Herbalist & Green Witch Gifts

The Herbal Apprentice Box is perfect for aspiring herbalists and green witches, delivering dried herbs, seeds, and recipes to expand their knowledge of plant magic. For a balance of crystals and mindfulness, Magickal Earth – Basic Crystal pairs stones with astrology and ritual tools to support an earth-based practice.

The Apothecary Crate and Sacred Space Crate also shine in this category, offering blends, botanicals, and altar items to nurture body, spirit, and sacred space.

Specialty Witch Gifts

If you’re seeking something truly unique, Past Box: Romance and Ritual delivers themed collections around love, connection, and intention — perfect for gifting on special occasions.

Want to see even more? Explore our full Witchy & Occult Collection for altar tools, crystals, and magickal goodies.