Your Cart is Empty
Explore Our Popular Categories
Collection
Murder Mystery Game Night in a Box
Escape boredom with our best escape room and murder mystery subscription boxes!
Best in Category 2023
The Deadbolt Mystery Society Monthly Boxby Deadbolt Mystery Society
Unbox a mystery! Solve a crime! Close the case! A new standalone mystery every month!
From
$23.67 / box
1st box
50% off
Best of 2023
Finders Seekers Mysteriesby Finders Seekers Mysteries
A thrilling mystery game! (without any sensationalized murders) Explore the world solving puzzles & mysteries while collaborating with others!
From
$26.40 / box
1st box
25% off
Editor's Picks 2023
Escape the Crate: An Escape Room Adventure shipped straight to your door.by Escape the Crate
A bi-monthly "Escape Room" subscription box game... full of puzzles and mysteries to solve! NO WAITING! SHIPS OUT IN 2 - 4 DAYS!
From
$26.50 / box
Ships Fast
1st box
50% off
Preferred Seller
The Conundrum Box - Escape Room Game in a Boxby The Conundrum Box
Escape boredom! A monthly adventure box, part escape room, part choose-your-own adventure!
From
$27.80 / box
Ships Fast
Low Stock
Best New Box 2023
Murder & Co.by Murder & Co
Intelligent crime solving meets a lifestyle subscription box.
From
$60.00 / box
Ships Fast
Cross Stitch Crime
by Cross Stitch Crime
Cozy, playable mysteries to challenge your mind. Mini cross stitch kits to channel your creativity.
From
$29.99 / box
The Resystance
by Madmen & Heroes
Disentangle puzzles, ciphers & history-based mysteries.
From
$31.50 / box
1st box
50% off
Preferred Seller
This Whodunit is KILLERby A Killing Affair
Serial Murder Mystery Game Delivered to Your Door Every Month!
From
$32.50 / box
Ships Fast
1st box
25% off
Be the Detective Monthly Mystery Subscription
by Be The Detective
An immersive detective mystery game that unravels over the course of three months.
From
$26.42 / box
Ships Fast
The CRAAAFT
by Madmen & Heroes
Disentangle puzzles, ciphers & history-based mysteries.
From
$31.50 / box
Preferred Seller
ForensiKitby ForensiKit by Crime Scene
Each ForensiKit explores a different technique used in working a crime scene.
From
$43.75 / box
Preferred Seller
Sin Cityby A Killing Affair
Become the Detective in this Riveting Murder Mystery Game!
From
$32.50 / box
CosyKiller: For the Armchair Sleuth.
by Cosykiller
Crack the case with this interactive murder mystery subscription box.
From
$40.83 / box
Free Shipping
1st box
25% off
Scarlet Envelope: Secret Society Subscription
by Scarlet Envelope
Solve a series of immersive mysteries all set in different times and worlds!
From
$21.50 / box
1st box
25% off
Puzzling Newspaper Subscription - The Hincks Gazette
by Bluefish Games
Solve puzzles and explore the perplexing town of Hincksville. Perfect for board gamers, escape room players, and the curious-minded.
From
$23.00 / box
Ships Fast
1st box
25% off
Preferred Seller
The Conundrum Box LIGHT - One box every TWO monthsby The Conundrum Box
Escape boredom! A bimonthly adventure box, part escape room, part choose-your-own adventure!
From
$28.73 / box
Low Stock
Cryptic Case
by Escape Rooms Monthly
Enjoy a themed AR adventure (plus a cool laser-cut souvenier!) every month.
From
$26.50 / box
Free Shipping