The Best Gifts for College Guys Are Useful, Unique Subscriptions (2024)

The art of the mixtape isn’t lost on Vinyl Moon, a vinyl “mixtape” subscription box that combines the best new music (read: 10 new artists from around the world) with original artwork and stunning color-rich pressed vinyl to create an ultra-deluxe listening experience. There’s even a lyric book with band information included in each box so your record-lover can sing along to their new favorite tracks.

“Great job guys—nice eclectic mix. I am so happy that my daughter gifted CrateJoy to me. I love being exposed to new music.” — Jeff W.

With the Deadbolt Mystery Society, they can have a monthly immersive experience without the dead body to clean up. Each month brings them a unique, stand-alone box that includes intriguing scenarios, lively characters, and fascinating stories.

“I've been a customer since the beginning. I love the all-in-one monthly boxes. I've collected every box released but until this year, I never completed any. But now I have monthly murder mystery nights with my friends and we have a huge collection to choose from so we're never bored! Highly recommend DMS over all the other subscription boxes.” – Amanda A.

Specialty noodles from around the world arrive every month in noodle packs, instant bowls or a mix of both, treating your lucky recipient to delicious flavors and new styles, all taste-tested by their very own Ramen King. Each box contains a pamphlet with a description of each noodle treat in your box as well.

“We absolutely love this subscription box. We have enjoyed noods for over a year and can't remember any duplicates, although some boxes have come with similar Ramen in them. We have bought some of the Ramen we've loved from our monthly boxes. Exotic Noods is a really fun and delicious subscription box.” – Nancy G.

For comic collectors, Comic Mystery Box delivers 15 collector’s comics from new issues to variants. Each box comes with $60 worth of comics, including vintage issues dating back 30-40 years.

“Received lots of great comics and options to read, even helped me discover some I didn't know existed. The comics arrive well packaged and protected, I'm very happy and hope to continue this subscription for a long time to come!” – Khaezarn

Jerky Snob takes dried meats seriously. Beef jerky makes for the perfect snack for road trips, while watching Netflix, and even on the way to the gym. Whether they're a dried meat connoisseur or looking for another source of protein, Jerky Snob curates premium handcrafted jerky from small-batch artisans. Choose between 3 different levels, sending from 2 bags up to a full pound, for a variety of protein-packed tasty products.

“My S.O. loved these! I got this for him for his birthday and he thoroughly enjoyed looking forward to a new delivery each month. The jerky was really good, exceptionally fresh! Even his least favorite jerky's, the sugar free ones, were pretty good. They just need some kin of sweetness to balance out the flavor. All in all this was a wonderful experience and will be my first stop for future gifts!” -Donna H.

Dungeon Crate is a monthly subscription box that's going to take their tabletop setup to the next level. One of the best subscription boxes for Dungeon Masters and D&D guilds, this box is curated by in-the-know, experienced gamers who handpick and deliver a whole lotta loot, including RPG accessories, miniatures, and dice, plus downloadable adventures, campaigns, and maps.

"Gave a 3mos sub to my 17yo son for his birthday and he LOVES it. He's into D&D, MTG, Yugioh and Pathfinder. He's asked for another 3mos for Christmas." - Leslie M.

Men can also appreciate a great beauty box especially when it comes to luxury essentials. He Time By My Me Time is a great gift for men who may be looking to try new and premium grooming and lifestyle products. Each box includes 8 to 10 items such as skincare and body products, aromatherapy, accessories, and gourmet goodies.

“I bought a two-box subscription for my 20-something son. He opened the first one under the Christmas tree and loved it. His second box just arrived. It is even better than the first. I am very impressed with the selection and how the items complement each other.” – Robin D.

Whether he's a workaholic with very little time on his hands or a young man just starting out on his own, the All He Loves Box is a great way to get him the high-quality gear he needs to make the most of life. Merging convenience and preparedness, each box sends a curated mix of practical premium lifestyle products, including handyman tools, tech gadgets, survival gear and more.

“This was such a fun box and the quality of the items was great. I was surprised at how fast they shipped it as well. I will buy from this seller again.” - Lara H.