8 Perfect Picks for Your Next Murder Mystery Game Night

Updated by Amy Furr

With summer here and restrictions slowly beginning to lift, you might find yourself considering a small in-person social gathering for the first time since New Years 2020.

We’re huge proponents of a game night full of fun games, and we have an awesome array of them for you to choose from. But, while we all love a good night of classic board games or clever scavenger hunts, there’s no better way to break the ice than to crack a case — that’s why a murder mystery party with a twist is the way to go! The storyline of a murder mystery party game will give you and your friends plenty to talk about and explore as a group. And, because many murder mystery game subscriptions are ongoing over several shipments, you have the perfect excuse to get back together month after month.

So...let’s get you ready for a night of mystery and intrigue! Clear time on the calendar and tell the gang to leave the kids at home. (Make this an adult party; a murder mystery party game with true-crime elements is too much for little ones or even tweens.) Then, you must choose your mystery-themed whodunnit, of course.

On the Cratejoy Marketplace, you'll find numerous murder mystery dinner party and escape room ideas for you to choose from, including virtual murder mystery games, mystery board games, and more party kits to test your sleuth skills. But to simplify things, we’ve picked a handful of our faves for in-person play, plus a few party ideas for a game night done right. Read on for the rundown!

Party Kits Perfect for Your Murder Mystery Game Night

Shaker & Spoon Cocktail Club

Shaker & Spoon Cocktail Club

From $49.91 per box
Buy Now

Mix things up by giving them a craft cocktail subscription box. Each month, subscribers will get three unique and tasty cocktail recipes, along with everything needed (minus the liquor) to whip up 12 delicious drinks. Every Shaker & Spoon box focuses on a specific liquor, so they’ll be able to make the most of their home bar. Whether they’re celebrating a special occasion, getting together with friends, or just building their bartender expertise, this monthly box will have subscribers raising a glass in delight.

Shipping: The Vodka Brunch Box is shipping now! **IF YOU EVER NEED A BOX SOONER, WRITE TO US by clicking the CONTACT SELLER button (bottom of the page) to let us know and we’ll send your box (or a different box of your choice from our vault) out ASAP!**

Customer Review

"Gave this as a gift and got to try some of the cocktails. The cachaca box was really fun! Really interesting combinations and usually some ingredients leftover for another batch of cocktails." - Leyna M.

This Whodunit is KILLER

This Whodunit is KILLER

From $32.50 per box
Buy Now

A Killing Affair goes digital with the immersive murder mystery in a box and the online components. It's like watching your favorite TV show; subscribers start with the first episode and each season has five episodes. This mystery experience knocks storytelling out of the park.

Shipping: We are committed to getting your first episode to you before Christmas. USPS is currently stating a 4-5 days turnaround. Orders received by noon ship the same day and afternoon are shipped the next day. If you place the order and are worried it will not make it in time we are happy to email a printable certificate for under the tree!

Customer Review

“I recently finished the first season and had to order more. This is just so well done! You get a file folder with witness statements, a case report, and autopsy results for each victim, and there are little evidence bags. Over 5 boxes, the story develops, and you clear some suspects with each box. So much thought went into all of the details! I highly recommend this subscription.” - Stacy B.

Monthly Popcorn Subscription

Monthly Popcorn Subscription

From $15.49 per box
Buy Now

Popped fresh before shipping, every delicious morsel of popcorn brought by Kernel Crate delivers a one-of-a-kind taste experience. All about bringing fun new flavors to popcorn lovers around the world, with each monthly delivery of Kernel Crate, they'll find 3 bags of uniquely-flavored (and naturally gluten-free) popcorn. From flavors like sweet cinnamon roll and horchata to savory BBQ bacon and pickle, now's the time to get in on the ultimate popcorn grab bag!

Shipping: All new or renewal orders placed between 1st through the 14th are shipped on the 15th. All new or renewal orders placed between the 15th through the end of the month are shipped on the 1st of the following month.

Customer Review

"It is always such a joy to get my box of popcorn in for the month! My parents and I have movie nights when I come to visit them, and this subscription for my dad has been such a fun part of that. Thanks y'all!" - Helen M.

Monthly Mocktail Box - Raising the Bar

Monthly Mocktail Box - Raising the Bar

From $60.00 per box
Buy Now

This delicious subscription service features alcohol-free beverage kits that make it easy to mix sparkly, seasonally-flavored concoctions. Get them prepped with all they'll need, like fresh spices, handcrafted syrups, barware and more.

Shipping: Boxes ship out mid-month.

Customer Review

“Love, love, love this gift! Fantastic box - thoroughly enjoyed every detail. I was especially impressed with the thoughtful garnish - which was included. We already purchased more of the sparking NA wine and mixer. Great way to get turned on to new products/vendors for those of us not imbibing.” – Rachel K.

SnackSack Classic

SnackSack Classic

From $26.91 per box
Buy Now

Looking for the ultimate snacking subscription? This box delivers between 11 and 13 surprise snacks every month centered around a fun or seasonal theme. There are four snacking plans to fit different lifestyles: classic, vegan, gluten-free, or vegan and gluten-free.

Shipping: Secure your April SnackSack today, shipping on April 18th! Act fast – limited quantities available until sold out. Don't miss out on our "Mother Earth" theme, celebrating Earth Day with an array of refreshing snacks and spring flavors! Order now to guarantee your spot in this delicious adventure!

Customer Review

“I am enjoying everything that came in my monthly box, there wasn't a bad snack in the entire selection! Also, I love the cute bag to keep my snacks in; it's a really nice touch. I can't wait to see what other delights are in the other months to come.” — Kareema B.

More to Explore

Mystery and Horror Book Clubs
Tea Subscription Boxes
Candy Subscription Boxes

Shop Gifts

Unique Gifts
Gifts for Book Lovers
Gifts for Foodies