The Best Halloween Subscription Boxes for Year-Round Spooky Horror

Updated by Shannon Ratliff

Halloween isn't just a day, it's a state of mind. Whether you're gearing up for October 31st or you want to celebrate the spooky season year-round, the best Halloween subscription boxes bring the season to you. The curated themes of the best horror subscription boxes make you say, "I never would've found this," and it's true because every item is specially curated by Halloween fans from all over the world.

What does a monthly subscription box for Halloween include?

Halloween-themed boxes are as unique as the curators themselves. You can find Halloween-focused home decor, stationary with jack-o-lantern stickers, orange and black bath bombs, movie horror packs, and even face-painting kits.

Whether you're looking for the best spooky box club or want to send a gift to the horror movie collectible fan in your life, the Cratejoy market has your geeky and gaming needs covered in a spooky subscription box. Some boxes are Halloween-themed all year, while some below send specifically themed boxes in October.

What are the best Halloween subscription boxes?

Skulls Unlimited's BoneBox

Skulls Unlimited's BoneBox

From $24.99 per box
Buy Now

What's spookier than adding some real skulls to your home decor? Skulls Unlimited's BoneBox is one of the most unique subscription boxes out there, delivering new osteological specimens every month! This creepy crate brings real, professionally cleaned bones, from skulls, teeth, and claws to baculum and other intriguing finds.

Shipping: New Subscribers: We ship the 1st full week of the month. Please order by the 30th to get the next month's box. Existing Subscribers: Boxes ship the 1st full week of the month and subscriptions renew on the 15th of every month. *Holidays may cause delays*

Customer Review

"I love this box! All of the bones are high quality, and unique. I love the information about the species with each bone as well. I highly recommend!" - Paige W.

NME Box

NME Box

From $59.57 per box
Buy Now

Are they an aspiring makeup artist, or someone who loves to design an elaborate costume for ComicCon or DragonCon each year? Then this box is for them! Boxes are packed with everything from makeup to wigs to prosthetics to help them create movie-ready looks!

Shipping: Boxes ship to subscribers during the first 10 days of the month. New purchases ship within 14 days of order. (Ex. A one-time purchase on Aug 10th ships by Aug 24th.). Subscription renewals take place on the 11th of every month.

Customer Review

“Loved this subscription! Each box was well thought out and included some pretty cool makeup. Plus the wigs were amazing. The owner responded quickly and even gave ideas on her Pinterest page for possible cosplay looks. Definitely looked forward to each box during the Covid months!” – Sandy B.

Cryptid Crate Monthy Subscription Box - Cratejoy Edition

Cryptid Crate Monthy Subscription Box - Cratejoy Edition

From $43.00 per box
Buy Now

Happy subscribers attest that the team at Cryptid Crate goes above and beyond, curating delightful collections of all things cryptozoological. A great gift idea for any teen who's into the not-yet-substantiated species of the world, each monthly box delivers 4 to 7 handpicked curiosities, including graphic T-shirts, offbeat decor items, intriguing accessories, and books and films from some of the best independent producers and artisans in the game.

Shipping: - Cryptid Crate ships on the first weekday of every month (will ship a day or two earlier or later if first weekday is a holiday) - Every box will ordered within a calendar month will be included in the shipment that goes out on the 1st.

Customer Review

“Amazing! I was so excited to get this box and it did not disappoint! LOVE the t-shirt and one of my new favorite stickers came in this box. Can't wait for next month!!!” – Megan S.

Spooky bath box

Spooky bath box

From $25.64 per box
Buy Now

The Bath & Bubbles box delivers a dose of cutely creepy bath products and surprises to your lair in its Spooky Bath Box. The self-care items include bath bombs, soaps, scrubs, and bubble baths that are cruelty-free. This beauty-themed subscription service is a fan-favorite for gifting to loved ones, as well as a batty treat for themselves.

Shipping: We ship within the first week bi-monthly in October, December, February, April, June, & August. For example: If you subscribe between August 1 and September 30, your next box will be shipped the first week of October. We do offer mystery and past boxes in our shop if you're too excited to wait!

Customer Review

"Absolutely loved this box. Will definitely keep up this subscription!" - Lynn S.

Blend Box  Always 8 or MORE* Adorable Unique products!

Blend Box Always 8 or MORE* Adorable Unique products!

From $18.25 per box
Buy Now

Operating from a vintage RV that's touring the USA, the woman-owned Blend Box is weird and wacky in all the right ways! Like a choose-your-own adventure in subscription box form, you'll pre-approve themes to get a mix of at least 8 smile-inducing goodies. With options like Sugar Skulls and Punk Rock, Happy Hangover, or The Cat Lady, you're guaranteed to find something that's right up your alley.

Shipping: Shipped via USPS First Class Mail - Fits in Nearly ALL mailboxes.

Paranormal T-Shirt Puzzle Subscription

Paranormal T-Shirt Puzzle Subscription

From $17.41 per box
Buy Now

Shipping: If your order is received during the first week of the month, it will ship with the current batch. If it is received after that shipment has gone out, your subscription will start the following month.

This Whodunit is KILLER

This Whodunit is KILLER

From $32.50 per box
Buy Now

A Killing Affair goes digital with the immersive murder mystery in a box and the online components. It's like watching your favorite TV show; subscribers start with the first episode and each season has five episodes. This mystery experience knocks storytelling out of the park.

Shipping: We are committed to getting your first episode to you before Christmas. USPS is currently stating a 4-5 days turnaround. Orders received by noon ship the same day and afternoon are shipped the next day. If you place the order and are worried it will not make it in time we are happy to email a printable certificate for under the tree!

Customer Review

“I recently finished the first season and had to order more. This is just so well done! You get a file folder with witness statements, a case report, and autopsy results for each victim, and there are little evidence bags. Over 5 boxes, the story develops, and you clear some suspects with each box. So much thought went into all of the details! I highly recommend this subscription.” - Stacy B.

Finders Seekers Mysteries

Finders Seekers Mysteries

From $26.40 per box
Buy Now

Solve puzzles while traveling the world with this thrilling escape room game! Finders Seekers is the perfect gift for puzzle solvers and mystery fans who loves a challenge! Enjoy this game with the family or venture off and uncover complex clues with a single use mystery game inclusive of hands-on and online gameplay.

Shipping: We ship on the 23rd of each month, for all orders placed by the 21st. All subsequent games will ship by the 23rd of each month. For last-minute gifts, we provide a fun PDF gift message that you can personalize and email or print. Shipping is $6 within the US, Canada shipping: $7.95.

Customer Review

“I have been getting Finders Seekers boxes for over a year, and I cannot lie, I'm obsessed. The mysteries are a lot of fun, and they are so much fun to do with friends, especially those that haven't done something like this before. Occasionally, the puzzles are evil (I'm looking at you, Paris box!), but the fact that after a year they can still challenge me is a good thing.” - Rachel C.

Find even more spooktacular picks for Halloween: Spooky Halloween Boxes