Best Halloween Subscription Boxes

Updated by Natasha Johnson

 

Halloween is a vibe. Whether you're counting down to October 31 or you like your thrills year‑round, these Halloween subscription boxes deliver spooky fun to your door. From witchy ritual kits to escape‑room mysteries and horror reads, these are the picks our readers actually keep.

What comes in a Halloween box

  • Witchy and occult: ritual tools, herbs, altar items, crystals

  • Puzzles and escape games: ciphers, clue packets, story booklets

  • Horror and fandom: apparel, collectibles, pins, props

  • Books: crime, thriller, and mystery favorites

How we chose
Recent orders, strong reviews, clear shipping, and themes that fit spooky season beyond October.

Solve puzzles while traveling the world with this thrilling escape room game! Finders Seekers is the perfect gift for puzzle solvers and mystery fans who loves a challenge! Enjoy this game with the family or venture off and uncover complex clues with a single use mystery game inclusive of hands-on and online gameplay.

Shipping · We ship on the 23rd of each month, for all orders placed by the 21st. All subsequent games will ship by the 23rd of each month. For last-minute gifts, we provide a fun PDF gift message that you can personalize and email or print. Shipping is $6 within the US, Canada shipping: $7.95.

Customer Review

“I have been getting Finders Seekers boxes for over a year, and I cannot lie, I'm obsessed. The mysteries are a lot of fun, and they are so much fun to do with friends, especially those that haven't done something like this before. Occasionally, the puzzles are evil (I'm looking at you, Paris box!), but the fact that after a year they can still challenge me is a good thing.” - Rachel C.

Buy Now

Featuring handcrafted, exclusive items to help any aspiring witch or pagan to deepen their craft and branch out into new directions, every witchcraft subscription box from The Witches Moon packs in an incredible value sending 10-20 unique items. Gift some spiritual practice goodies like hand-rolled spell candles, oracle and tarot cards, herbs, body care, spells and grimoire artwork for their very own book of shadows.

Shipping · If subscribing in October, your first box will ship between November 1st and 10th. As soon as your label is printed, you will receive an email with tracking information included. Most packages are shipped via USPS. Renewals are processed on the 15th of each month following the initial purchase of the subscription.

Customer Review

"Wow! Fantastic! Definitely worth the price paid! I received some really nice items beautifully curated around a theme. Everything in the box made sense and the quality of each item was way above my expectations! The box smelled soooo good when I opened it and every item felt like a treasure! Very happy with this purchase!” - April V.

Buy Now

Game #23 - Escape the Ripper (Single Game): Thrilling 1-hour escape room adventure! Solve puzzles, crack codes, and uncover mysteries to escape from the room. Ripper and family-friendly versions included.

Shipping · ALL ORDERS SHIP OUT WITHIN 2-4 DAYS OF BEING ORDERED! We are a bi-monthly subscription, meaning we ship every OTHER month. That means if you order a 2 month subscription, that is for only 1 box.

Customer Review
The puzzles were a mix of easy and more complex which kept it from getting too boring or too frustrating. It was fun and challenging. Also liked the convenience of 3 chapters so it could be broken up if needed.
Buy Now

The Natural Craft is expertly and thoughtfully curated in this subscription box that focuses on the Magick flowing in their life. Altar items like dried herbs, magickal flowers, and spell coins add depth to their daily practice each month.

Shipping · If subscribing in October, your first box will ship between November 1st and 10th. As soon as your label is printed, you will receive an email with tracking information included. Renewals are processed on the 11th of each month following the initial purchase of the subscription. Shipping Cost: $6.00 (Subject to change)

Customer Review

“Received my first witch’s roots box. I got the lunar box. It’s great. Came with a little of this and a little of that. They have inspired me to start my book of shadows and start collecting all the little beautiful things I buy/find along my journey. Beautiful and put together very well for someone experienced or a newb. Thanks for the awesome start to a beautiful beginning.” - Kelly C.

Buy Now

Unbox a mystery! Examine Evidence. Question Suspects. Search For Clues. Solve Puzzles. Close the case! FREE US Shipping

Shipping · FREE US SHIPPING. Subscriptions are taken from the first day of the month through the last day of the month at 6PM CST. Boxes ship to subscribers the first week of the following month. (Ex. Subscriptions from Dec 1-31 ship the first week of Jan 2025). Subscription renewals take place on the 15th of every month.

Customer Review
Love this company! I'm so excited every month to receive my box, and I check the website constantly for other mysteries that aren't part of the monthly subscription. They are a great way to decompress, have fun, and "excercise your brain".
Buy Now

Discover gripping new tales with this surprise mystery box containing 4 carefully curated, lesser-known crime, thriller & mystery books that will keep you turning pages all night.

Shipping · Boxes arrive every other month. Subscriptions automatically renew. Skip/Cancel anytime. "Your first box will ship within 2-6 business days after your order is placed & for united states customers box will be delivered within 3-4 weeks"

Customer Review
The order was never delivered. I have tried numerous times to contact you to no avail. WHERE IS MY ORDER???
Buy Now

Best thriller books delivered right to you, featuring the latest bestsellers and hidden gems from top authors. Perfect for fans of mystery, crime, and psychological suspense!

Shipping · FREE SHIPPING on all orders from USA and Canada!

Customer Review
Everything as expected and as described in the product listing so overall very good experience
Buy Now

The Conundrum Box is a new mystery and adventure box that delivers part escape room experience, part choose your own adventure! Each month builds on an exciting narrative with puzzles, clues, and ciphers to crack the case and solve the mystery. Boxes can also be solved as a stand-alone mystery and revolve around a new theme!

Shipping · We ship USPS first class. All domestic orders placed by 12/17/24 will be shipped by 12/18 in order to make USPS's 12/24 guaranteed arrival. Orders placed on or after 12/18/23 will ship the next business day. Arrival by 12/24 not guaranteed. In most cases, the games come in a branded mailer box with the title of the game on it.

Customer Review

“Conundrum box deliveries truly clever and unique puzzles every month. I am always impressed by the fun themes and props and everything they do to increase the immersive experience.” - Christopher B.

Buy Now

Handcrafted Sabbat ritual experiences featuring original spellwork, artisan botanical creations & guided rituals created in season. Weave the Sabbats into a complete seasonal practice. All 8 Sabbats.

Shipping · Sabbat Boxes ship approximately 6–10 days before each Sabbat, allowing time for your box to arrive before the seasonal threshold. Your first box will be the next available Sabbat Box in the turning Wheel. Free U.S. shipping.

Customer Review
Great quality & authentic rituals- love these boxes!!
Buy Now

A great gift is The Witches Bounty by The Witches Moon, a monthly subscription that's packed with quality tools to help her explore spirituality. Each beautifully curated monthly box delivers a coordinating pendant, crystal and anointing oil based on unique energies throughout the year. Known for its energy vortexes and metaphysical communities, each exquisite one-of-a-kind pendant has been charged in Sedona, Arizona.

Shipping · If subscribing in October, your first box will ship between November 1st and 10th. As soon as your label is printed, you will receive an email with tracking information included. Renewals are processed on the 15th of each month following the initial purchase of the subscription.

Customer Review

"An absolutely beautiful box which includes a stunning high quality jewelry pendant, a beautiful art page about the featured item, natural scented custom incense, custom made oil, and rolled beeswax candle. My attached image has my last 4 months( I accidentally left out the art for Isis jewelry photo, but it's also stunning featuring yellows and blues)" - Allison T.

Buy Now

A Killing Affair goes digital with the immersive murder mystery in a box and the online components. It's like watching your favorite TV show; subscribers start with the first episode and each season has five episodes. This mystery experience knocks storytelling out of the park.

Shipping · We are committed to getting your first episode to you before Christmas. USPS is currently stating a 4-5 days turnaround. Orders received by noon ship the same day and afternoon are shipped the next day. If you place the order and are worried it will not make it in time we are happy to email a printable certificate for under the tree!

Customer Review

“I recently finished the first season and had to order more. This is just so well done! You get a file folder with witness statements, a case report, and autopsy results for each victim, and there are little evidence bags. Over 5 boxes, the story develops, and you clear some suspects with each box. So much thought went into all of the details! I highly recommend this subscription.” - Stacy B.

Buy Now

Gothic Beauty Box - Gothic Beauty Magazine and goth goodies

Shipping · Gothic Beauty Box #58 & #59 are in stock for immediate shipping, including fast gift-giving. Starting Sept 13, 2025, new single crate orders receive Gothic Beauty Box #59. To automatically start with #58 and get TWO Boxes right away, please select 2 Box sub or greater.

Customer Review
Throughly enjoy the box! So much fun. I have enjoyed every item included in the box.
Buy Now

Dive into the depths of suspense with Deadly Delights and transform your reading routine into an adventure!

Shipping · Welcome boxes are shipped immediately! Your first box will ship immediately within 1-3 business days of your order. Subsequent boxes will ship on the 11th of each month. We ship around the 11th of each month!

Customer Review
First order was really awesome. Was slightly disappointed in the October order since I thought it would have better goodies. Books were ok but mostly leaned towards mystery not horror
Buy Now

Tarot Box Ships First, then choose from over 30 additional box themes for upcoming months.

Shipping · We ship within 24 hours of purchase.

Customer Review
I got the miniatures box from blendbox and everything in it was absolutely adorable. I loved the little drink vending machine that actually vends tiny little soda cans! The box was filled to the limit, and packed tetris style so they every
Buy Now

Stop watching true crime and start solving it. The ForensiKit delivers professional-grade forensic supplies & hands-on case activities to your door every month, teaching you real crime scene methods.

Shipping · Your box will ship on the 2nd Friday of every month. Order by 8:00 a.m. Pacific on the 2nd Friday to get the current box.

Customer Review
I love everything about this box. Fingerprinting!!! Amazing.
Buy Now

Celebrate every holiday with a monthly snack box! Each month brings festive candy, snacks, and surprises themed to the season — from spooky Halloween treats to cozy Christmas goodies.

Shipping · Future boxes will ship about a week before each holiday, usually in the first week of the month. Delivery takes 3–5 business days, but delivery dates may vary and aren’t guaranteed.

Customer Review
For 3 month subscription for 113 dollars, this is a total rip off, in the box was literally basic candy, and very little of it. I guess I didn’t think they would choose some cheap ass candy… like I basically could have gone to target and bo
Buy Now

Art supplies are a great idea for kids in your life who are creative and looking for an outlet far beyond iPads. Even if they don’t know they’re crafty (yet!) The Kids Craft: Monthly DIY Kids Craft Box may awaken some latent creativity they never knew was there. Designed for children between the ages of three and nine, this unique monthly subscription featuring DIY crafting supplies, step-by-step instructions, fun facts, and an engaging story will keep new crafters engaged for hours.

Shipping · Enjoy hassle-free delivery! Our Kids Crafts Monthly Subscription Box ships globally. The first box is shipped within 1-5 business days. Expect your curated creativity kit at your doorstep by the 15th of each month. Track your box, and let the crafting adventures begin!

Customer Review

“Received this as a gift. Nice colorful craft box. Very satisfied and will definitely subscribe for a monthly box. Hours of fun. My 10yr old thoroughly loved it.” — Maria G.

Buy Now

Receive a surprise dessert kit every month featuring a unique recipe, pre‑measured premium ingredients, baking tools, keepsake recipe card, and free shipping - plus a welcome gift in your first box.

Shipping · Order by the last day of the month to be included in the next month's shipment. First Box ships by the 7th of the following month. Subsequent boxes ship by the 7th of each subsequent month. FREE SHIPPING via UPS (Ground) or USPS (Priority).

Customer Review
It was enjoyable to make the January sticky toffee pudding. Had to freeze some since there are only two of us. I have only made caramel once previously and forgot that it takes so long to do it correctly. My only comment is that I would hav
Buy Now

Fresh BAKED goodies shipped to your door each month!

Shipping · Baked Boxes are shipped via UPS or USPS and arrive within 3-5 business days of shipping Expect your next box to be shipped the first Monday of the first full week of the month Monthly subscribers and renewals will ship 5 business days after 11th if you purchase after the 25th of the month you will receive the next months box

Customer Review
Loved this box!! The cookies were themed so cute, and tasted delicious!! 10/10!
Buy Now

How to pick
Theme fit, budget filters (Under 35, 35‑60, 60‑100, 100+), and ship windows if you want Halloween‑week delivery.

Related guides

Keep shopping