Best New York Bagel

Delivering the best NY bagels right to your door!

Plans as low as $23.23 / week
Shipping & Renewal Information
  • Shipping OUT the week it is order and then the First or Third Week of the Month. Usually arrives on Thursday to Saturday. (Depending on your location in the US) Saturday arrival is available in some locations. If you have a specific request feel free to reach out thus. We are flexible on flavors and delivery date.
  • Ships worldwide from United States
  • Subscriptions automatically renew. Cancel anytime

Best New York Bagel

Delivering the best NY bagels right to your door!

Join the NY bagel club
Best NY Bagel delivers premium and delicious New York bagels to your door, at your desired rate. We ensure that the quality of our bagels cannot be beat! Subscribe and bring a little taste of NY into your home.
  • 7 subscription options to choose from
  • Pick your favorite flavors!
  • Ships weekly or monthly
  • New York Bagels
  • NEW YORK GIFT

Reviews (13)

Fresh and delicious!

6 days ago
Overall
Shipping
Quality
Curation
Luca M.
4 Reviews
1 Picture
9 Helpful
Subscribed for 17 days

The bagels are fantastic, and shipping was pretty quick. I'm way out in Texas, but they still arrived fresh.
They come with a printout of the ingredients and nutritional information, which was very convenient, as I live with several vegans. (Most of the bagels appear to be vegan. You can guess likely which ones aren't.)

Verified Purchase

Delicious!

Nov 12, 2019
Overall
Shipping
Quality
Dakotawinter B.
1 Review

The bagels showed up well packaged in resealable bags and were very fresh! I am really enjoying the bagels; they give me something to look forward to in the morning!

Changing review

May 24, 2018
Overall
Cynthia C.
6 Reviews
8 Helpful
Subscribed for 1 month

I originally left a negative review because I was charged but never got my bagels. I attempted to reach the seller and had trouble. I am now changing my opinion because he did reach out to me, assured me that it was a human oversight in that UPS never picked up the order. He then made it right and sent me an extra dozen. I just ate a blueberry one and have to say it was yummy 😋. I can’t wait to try a sesame seed one for breakfast with cream cheese, capers, and salmon. I will give them another try next month. Thanks for fixing the issue.

Verified Purchase

Great bagels!!!

May 11, 2018
Overall
Randi B.
2 Reviews
1 Helpful
Subscribed for 2 months

These bagels are delicious! I never had a French toast bagel before but decided to try it. My whole family loved them! The plain bagels were the best too! 😁

Verified Purchase

Amazing, fresh bagels!

Dec 11, 2017
Overall
Emily B.
1 Review
4 Helpful
Subscribed for 4 months

These bagels are DELICIOUS. They were shipped super-quickly all the way out to Texas and were fresh and delicious. I got sesame bagels and plain bagels this month, but I'm already looking forward to picking new bagel flavors for next month!

Verified Purchase

Outstanding

Dec 23, 2016
Overall
Todd H.
1 Review
Subscribed for 2 months

Omg these bagels are the best I've had.... ever. Here in two days and still fresh

Verified Purchase

Awesome Bagels!!

Jul 14, 2016
Overall
Shelly P.
1 Review
Subscribed for 2 years

These bagels are delicious and the company stands behind their product Chris was wonderful I had a slight problem I'm going to order and he fixed it in a timely manner and he was courteous and helpful throughout our interactions, love this company!! Sincerely Shelly Patrick/Scott Ferland

Verified Purchase

just ok

May 01, 2021
Overall
Shipping
Quality
Curation
Mike E.
1 Review
Subscribed for 2 months

Quite expensive for quality received.

Verified Purchase

No bagels, no response from owner

Jan 07, 2021
Overall
Ken J.
1 Review
Subscribed for 12 days

I can't seem to get bagels, or a response from the owner. I have received 3 separate emails saying my bagels have been shipped, each time I click on the tracking code and there is no location for the bagels. I have written 3 times to the owner, asking for help with this order, and gotten no response.

Verified Purchase
Best New York Bagel said...Jan 07, 2021

Hey Ken, Sorry we sent you on email on this. I am thinking it may of ended up in your spam. So we are trying here.
We are baking today and shipping. We are also throwing an extra dozen in there.
Sorry for the issue with USPS and we are trying to rectify.

Awful customer service

Dec 19, 2019
Overall
Shipping
Quality
Curation
Lauren M.
1 Review
3 Helpful
Subscribed for 2 months

I purchased these bagels for boyfriend who is from NY and the bagels arrived very, very moldy. I reached out the seller, cratejoy, and left a question on this site and never heard back. That was over two months ago. This product may be great, but the customer service is awful. Do not buy these bagels.

Verified Purchase

Customer Questions (12)

3

Q: Is there anyway to get plain egg bagels? I see egg everything but i just want them plainAsked by Mary J., June 2019

Best New York Bagel answered...June 2019

Sure.
If you have any issues. Let me know I will fix the order.
Thanks

Yes. Should be an option. If not I can alter after you place the order.

by Chris, June 2019

2

Q: I have read that you ship worldwide. I live in Italy and I would be very interested in your box. How do you ship overseas and how long does it take for the package to arrive? Thanks. Alice.Asked by Alice O., September 2020

No answers yet! Be the first to help by adding an answer below.


1

Q: My last shipment had all molded bagels and I reached out but haven't heard back. I have another shipment that shipped yesterday. How do I get in contact to get a refund?Asked by Lauren M., November 2019

No answers yet! Be the first to help by adding an answer below.


1

Q: How many bagels per boxAsked by Beverly W., June 2019

Best New York Bagel answered...June 2019

12 TO A DOZEN

Best New York Bagel appears in these collections...


Buy Now

Delivering the best NY bagels right to your door!

Choose a subscription