Chef-curated monthly collection of organic, small-batch nut butters paired with fruit spreads.

$27.00+ / month
Product Overview
  • If you sign up on January 10, we'll send your Welcome box and you'll have it by the 15th. Your next rebill date is February 10th, and your next shipment will follow thereafter.
  • Only ships within United States
  • Subscriptions automatically renew. Cancel anytime
Artisan nut butters and fruit spreads every month!
Each month you'll receive a combination of flavors to try. We carefully curate flavorful & fun combinations of products from organic and small-batch producers you're sure to love. All subscription plans include free shipping within the continental United States. Bring out the best in your lunch. Make your friends PB&Jealous.
  • Delicious, all-natural ingredients. New flavor combinations every month.
  • Enjoy delicious, chef-paired flavor combinations, like Whiskey Peach Jam + Honey Roasted Peanut Butter... or Blueberry Bourbon Vanilla Jam + Espresso Cocoa Nib Almond Butter... :)
  • We support small business and local, organic food.
Subscriber Reviews
4.5 of 5 stars
Sadly disappointed
by Michelle written last year
I ordered the $26.95 sweet box and was really looking forward to it. I received one jar of peanut butter, one jar of regular ol' grape jelly, two sample snack pouches of almond butter, three sample pouches of coconut chocolate peanut butter, and two small sample jars (one serving each) of a rum banana spread. Everything was tasty, but for the price I was hoping for more. I was going to give it one more month, but ultimately decided I would get more for my money on a trip to the organic grocery store or local farmers market. I would resub in a second if the price was lower or if the boxes were higher value.
by Heather written last year
First, everything was very well packaged, which is crucial when dealing with fragile items. Plus, it's an enjoyable package to open! I appreciate the nicely printed information card that provides information about each product. I subscribed to the sweet & savory mini box, and I'm impressed and pleased with the selection. I'm especially excited about receiving pepper jelly! It's not too spicy, which I think is important in order to appeal to as many subscribers as possible, and shows thoughtfulness in the curation. This is such a fantastic spin on the classic jelly of the month club, and I can't wait to discover new artisan delights through this subscription. I can't recommend this box enough!
by Lissa written last year
I am a crate box addict, and this is by far the one I've raved about the most and I just got my first one yesterday! It's a full box of full sized products and bonus samples. PB&JEALOUS, you nailed what create boxes should be! Thank you
Other boxes you might like...
Subscribe Now